Jesus Christ Superstar

Carly Smithson

Age: 24

Hometown: San Diego

Voted off: April 23

Lowlight: It was on a night dedicated to the songbook of Andrew Lloyd Webber that Carly delivered a strong performance of "Superstar" from the musical "Jesus Christ Superstar." This tattoo shop owner must have been... more surprised to be voted off given the feedback she received from the judges. Randy said her rendition was "definitely good." Even Simon confessed, "It was actually one of my favorite performances of the night." Go figure.

"Idol" Message Board: Sound off

(FOX)