Transamerica

:

Critics' Reviews

advertisement
Movie Title
Avg. Score
1.
Blind Side, The
2.
Twilight Saga: New Moon, The
6.
49
Metascore
®
66
Generally favorable reviews
out of 100
Huffman Lights Up 'Transamerica'
By Christy Lemire, Associated Press

A pre-op transsexual goes on a cross-country road trip with the teenage hustler son he never knew he had. Or would that be she?

It sounds like a bad soap-opera premise. But in the hands of "Transamerica" star Felicity Huffman, this potentially melodramatic idea produces a film that's funny, poignant and remarkably grounded in reality.

A recent Emmy winner for playing one of the Wisteria Lane women on "Desperate Housewives," Huffman is completely unrecognizable as the uber-girlie Bree (who's technically still a man named Stanley), a transformation she achieved not just through makeup, hair and clothing, but from the inside out.

Yes, the film's creative team gets the aesthetic elements right in depicting what it's like when a man pretends to be a woman — or in this case, when a woman acts like a man pretending to be a woman. Bree applies her makeup in bold smudges and hasn't found quite the right shades for her skin tone. Her wardrobe consists of pinks and polyesters, which would make her an ideal Mary Kay saleswoman. And when she tries to sashay gracefully, her walk comes off as a jerky stomp.

But it's what Huffman does internally — the sadness and the subtlety beneath the awkward exterior — that makes her so enormously believable. It helps greatly that writer-director Duncan Tucker, in his impressive feature film debut, has created a character who's not a freak or a stereotype, just a lonely, alienated person trying to establish an identity and find a little happiness.

Bree is clearly brilliant but aimless, having hopped between college courses and jobs before settling on telemarketing and part-time waitressing to save money for her operation. For someone whose lifestyle would be considered far outside the mainstream, she's surprisingly conservative and proper, which is an inventive twist.

She's appalled to find out not only that she has a son from a fleeting heterosexual encounter long ago but also that he's a junkie and a street hustler — with atrocious grammar. ("You don't have to say 'like,'" she scolds him for peppering his speech with slang. "'Probably disemboweled by a ninja' will suffice.")

She's only a week away from her surgery when she flies from California to New York (urged by her therapist, played by Elizabeth Peña) to meet Toby (Kevin Zegers), who's just been arrested and has placed a call for help to the person he believes is his father. Posing as a church missionary to hide her identity, she agrees to drive him back to Los Angeles, where he has dreams of starring in X-rated movies. She has dreams, meanwhile, of dropping him off with a relative somewhere along the way.

The road-trip premise is a cliché in itself, and Tucker gives in to all its conventions: a beat-up station wagon, two-lane back roads (no one in road-trip movies ever takes the highway), run-down gas stations and folksy diners. They encounter unscrupulous strangers and unexpected kindnesses (Graham Greene adds sweetness and warmth in just a few scenes).

And, most importantly, they get to know each other, which is inevitable when you're stuck in a car with someone for days at a time.

Zegers, who looks and sounds like a young Leonardo DiCaprio with his tousled hair and wiry frame, finds a natural banter with Huffman as their characters feel each other out and fail to tell each other the whole truth. Fionnula Flanagan, Burt Young and Carrie Preston provide comic relief as Bree's disapproving family, just as the story reaches its most intense point in Phoenix.

Of course, Toby and Bree will both be better off by the end of their travels, but this is one of those instances in which the journey truly is the destination.

A pre-op transsexual goes on a cross-country road trip with the teenage hustler son he never knew he had. Or would that be she?

It sounds like a bad soap-opera premise. But in the hands of "Transamerica" star Felicity Huffman, this potentially melodramatic idea produces a film that's funny, poignant and remarkably grounded in reality.

A recent Emmy winner for playing one of the Wisteria Lane women on "Desperate Housewives," Huffman is completely unrecognizable as the uber-girlie Bree (who's technically still a man named Stanley), a transformation she achieved not just through makeup, hair and clothing, but from the inside out.

Yes, the film's creative team gets the aesthetic elements right in depicting what it's like when a man pretends to be a woman — or in this case, when a woman acts like a man pretending to be a woman. Bree applies her makeup in bold smudges and hasn't found quite the right shades for her skin tone. Her wardrobe consists of pinks and polyesters, which would make her an ideal Mary Kay saleswoman. And when she tries to sashay gracefully, her walk comes off as a jerky stomp.

But it's what Huffman does internally — the sadness and the subtlety beneath the awkward exterior — that makes her so enormously believable. It helps greatly that writer-director Duncan Tucker, in his impressive feature film debut, has created a character who's not a freak or a stereotype, just a lonely, alienated person trying to establish an identity and find a little happiness.

Bree is clearly brilliant but aimless, having hopped between college courses and jobs before settling on telemarketing and part-time waitressing to save money for her operation. For someone whose lifestyle would be considered far outside the mainstream, she's surprisingly conservative and proper, which is an inventive twist.

She's appalled to find out not only that she has a son from a fleeting heterosexual encounter long ago but also that he's a junkie and a street hustler — with atrocious grammar. ("You don't have to say 'like,'" she scolds him for peppering his speech with slang. "'Probably disemboweled by a ninja' will suffice.")

She's only a week away from her surgery when she flies from California to New York (urged by her therapist, played by Elizabeth Peña) to meet Toby (Kevin Zegers), who's just been arrested and has placed a call for help to the person he believes is his father. Posing as a church missionary to hide her identity, she agrees to drive him back to Los Angeles, where he has dreams of starring in X-rated movies. She has dreams, meanwhile, of dropping him off with a relative somewhere along the way.

The road-trip premise is a cliché in itself, and Tucker gives in to all its conventions: a beat-up station wagon, two-lane back roads (no one in road-trip movies ever takes the highway), run-down gas stations and folksy diners. They encounter unscrupulous strangers and unexpected kindnesses (Graham Greene adds sweetness and warmth in just a few scenes).

And, most importantly, they get to know each other, which is inevitable when you're stuck in a car with someone for days at a time.

Zegers, who looks and sounds like a young Leonardo DiCaprio with his tousled hair and wiry frame, finds a natural banter with Huffman as their characters feel each other out and fail to tell each other the whole truth. Fionnula Flanagan, Burt Young and Carrie Preston provide comic relief as Bree's disapproving family, just as the story reaches its most intense point in Phoenix.

Of course, Toby and Bree will both be better off by the end of their travels, but this is one of those instances in which the journey truly is the destination.

80
Time: Joel Stein
But the most impressive thing is how, a few minutes into the film, you stop noticing Huffman's external transformations and start to focus on the character. Not that the external stuff isn't impressive.Read Full Review »
75
ROLLING STONE: Peter Travers
The movie's soul is with Huffman. Speaking in a low voice, her posture as stiff as her vocabulary, her eyes a pool of sadness and hope, she turns this small, resonant film into a cry from the heart.Read Full Review »
75
Philadelphia Inquirer: Steven Rea
It's a farce with heart, a meditation on identity, family and gender politics that has real faith in its characters - even when the characters themselves lack it.Read Full Review »
75
Boston Globe: Wesley Morris
It's debatable whether watching Huffman get dressed, take hormones, and learn to use a more feminine diction could sustain an entire movie, but the character is certainly a creation more original than a lot of the film itself.Read Full Review »
75
CHICAGO SUN-TIMES: Roger Ebert
What Felicity Huffman brings to Bree is the newness of a Jane Austen heroine. She has been waiting a long time to be an ingenue, and what an irony that she must begin as a mother.Read Full Review »
70
Slate: David Edelstein
Farce born of sadly irreconcilable impulses: Bravo!Read Full Review »
70
The New York Times: Dana Stevens
Transamerica itself does not always live up to its star, but it is touching and sometimes funny, despite its overall air of indie earnestness.Read Full Review »
70
Washington Post: Ann Hornaday
If Tucker's road map often feels a little too confining and the screwball comedy too contrived, he can take credit for introducing viewers to a character they have almost certainly never met before.Read Full Review »
67
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Lisa Schwarzbaum
The unintended effect of all the melodramatic complications in Transamerica is, oddly, to distract attention from an understanding of exactly what that courage really costs.Read Full Review »
63
ReelViews: James Berardinelli
As much heralded, "edgy" movies go, Transamerica fails to live up to expectations.Read Full Review »
See all Transamerica reviews at metacritic.com »