Too Many Girls

Too Many Girls is an acceptable and moderately entertaining film version of the Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart stage hit. If the musical was more entertaining on Broadway, that's essentially because -- as usual in the 1930s and '40s -- Hollywood jettisoned too much of the show's score (its biggest asset) for the film version. Still, the lovely "I Didn't Know What Time It Was" remains, as does the haunting "You're Nearer," the charming "Love Never Went to College," and the eyebrow-raising but energetic "Spic and Spanish." Frances Langford does a good job belting out her solos, Ann Miller dazzles every time she gets the chance to lead the dances, and a very young Desi Arnaz catches the eye during his solo moments. Lucille Ball's singing is dubbed (acceptably), but the acting is her own, and it's a fine performance. Those who know Ball only from television will probably be surprised at the subdued, natural way in which she handles her role. Richard Carlson looks good but is rather bland and Hal LeRoy is rather unbelievable, but Eddie Bracken is amusing and nobody is really damaging. Girls is pure froth, and if it's nothing to write home about, it's nicely packaged and easy to watch. ~ Craig Butler, All Movie Guide