This Christmas

:

Critics' Reviews

Metascore
®
63
Generally favorable reviews
out of 100
'This Christmas' a Rare Holiday Treat
By Lael Loewenstein, Variety.com

"This Christmas" is a rare holiday treat, a package that's both thoughtfully selected and sure to please its intended recipients. With its universal themes, highly marketable soundtrack and recognizable cast, this upbeat comedy centering on a black family's first reunion in four years has unique crossover potential for a variety of demographics, though Sony will have to work hard to make that happen theatrically. The pic should do respectable business this season but recoup very nicely as a holiday staple to be watched time and again.

Columbus Short and Idris Elba
Video: MSN talks to Short, Elba and Brown

With eager anticipation, family matriarch Ma'Dere Whitfield (Loretta Devine) awaits her brood's holiday homecoming. Joining her companion Joe (Delroy Lindo) and teenage son Baby (Chris Brown) are homemaker daughter Lisa (Regina King); tough but lonely businesswoman Kelli (Sharon Leal); conflicted college student Mel (Lauren London); returning Marine Claude (Columbus Short); and, surprisingly, traveling musician Quentin (Idris Elba). Current and prospective mates include Mel's beau Devean (Keith Robinson), Lisa's materialistic spouse, Malcolm (Laz Alonso); and a charming fireman (Mekhi Phifer) with eyes for Kelli.

That each of the family members conceals a secret to be revealed in time might seem formulaic, but Preston Whitmore II, helming his own script, has such an assured sense of rhythm and tone that the film moves smartly along. Various truths are exposed concerning Claude's lovelife and military status, Quentin's debts, Lisa's female intuition, Malcolm's extramarital activities and Baby's musical ambition, but these disclosures happen more or less organically. The latter revelation is the pic's sweetest surprise, as Brown ("Stomp the Yard"), a phenomenally talented performer, delivers a dazzling rendition of "Try a Little Tenderness."

That sequence is one of several musical interludes that fill "This Christmas" with an infectiously buoyant spirit. Brown also does a fine job with his climactic take on the title tune, and DeNetria Champ, as a gospel singer, offers a slow-building, deeply moving performance of "O Holy Night."

The soundtrack features a number of well-mounted holiday standards, including two family dance segments, the second of which feels like an indulgent, overlong coda that would have been better placed over the end credits. Still, it's unusual these days to find a holiday film that doesn't feel as recycled as a fruitcake.

Technical elements, including Alexander Gruszynski's lensing and Dawn Snyder's festive production design, are fine. Despite some recognizable L.A. locations and landmarks, including the El Rey Theater, the story's setting is never mentioned, and the pic is otherwise awfully heavy on the interiors.

The cast, led by veterans Lindo and Devine, is solid. If "This Christmas" is any indication, Whitmore, helming only his third feature (after the little-seen "Crossover" and "Walking Dead"), may well be a director to watch.

More on Variety.com

Copyright 2007 Variety, Inc. All rights reserved.

"This Christmas" is a rare holiday treat, a package that's both thoughtfully selected and sure to please its intended recipients. With its universal themes, highly marketable soundtrack and recognizable cast, this upbeat comedy centering on a black family's first reunion in four years has unique crossover potential for a variety of demographics, though Sony will have to work hard to make that happen theatrically. The pic should do respectable business this season but recoup very nicely as a holiday staple to be watched time and again.

Columbus Short and Idris Elba
Video: MSN talks to Short, Elba and Brown

With eager anticipation, family matriarch Ma'Dere Whitfield (Loretta Devine) awaits her brood's holiday homecoming. Joining her companion Joe (Delroy Lindo) and teenage son Baby (Chris Brown) are homemaker daughter Lisa (Regina King); tough but lonely businesswoman Kelli (Sharon Leal); conflicted college student Mel (Lauren London); returning Marine Claude (Columbus Short); and, surprisingly, traveling musician Quentin (Idris Elba). Current and prospective mates include Mel's beau Devean (Keith Robinson), Lisa's materialistic spouse, Malcolm (Laz Alonso); and a charming fireman (Mekhi Phifer) with eyes for Kelli.

That each of the family members conceals a secret to be revealed in time might seem formulaic, but Preston Whitmore II, helming his own script, has such an assured sense of rhythm and tone that the film moves smartly along. Various truths are exposed concerning Claude's lovelife and military status, Quentin's debts, Lisa's female intuition, Malcolm's extramarital activities and Baby's musical ambition, but these disclosures happen more or less organically. The latter revelation is the pic's sweetest surprise, as Brown ("Stomp the Yard"), a phenomenally talented performer, delivers a dazzling rendition of "Try a Little Tenderness."

That sequence is one of several musical interludes that fill "This Christmas" with an infectiously buoyant spirit. Brown also does a fine job with his climactic take on the title tune, and DeNetria Champ, as a gospel singer, offers a slow-building, deeply moving performance of "O Holy Night."

The soundtrack features a number of well-mounted holiday standards, including two family dance segments, the second of which feels like an indulgent, overlong coda that would have been better placed over the end credits. Still, it's unusual these days to find a holiday film that doesn't feel as recycled as a fruitcake.

Technical elements, including Alexander Gruszynski's lensing and Dawn Snyder's festive production design, are fine. Despite some recognizable L.A. locations and landmarks, including the El Rey Theater, the story's setting is never mentioned, and the pic is otherwise awfully heavy on the interiors.

The cast, led by veterans Lindo and Devine, is solid. If "This Christmas" is any indication, Whitmore, helming only his third feature (after the little-seen "Crossover" and "Walking Dead"), may well be a director to watch.

More on Variety.com

Copyright 2007 Variety, Inc. All rights reserved.

75
CHICAGO SUN-TIMES: Roger Ebert
What's surprising is how well Whitmore, the director, manages to direct traffic. He's got one crisis cooling, another problem exploding, a third dilemma gathering steam and people exchanging significant looks about secrets still not introduced. It's sort of a screwball-comedy effect, but with a heart.Read Full Review »
75
Philadelphia Inquirer: Carrie Rickey
At the multiplex where so many holiday movies feel regifted, This Christmas is a gift.Read Full Review »
75
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Lisa Schwarzbaum
Everyone in this madly good-looking clan has got soapy problems as befits an aspirational, say-amen holiday movie.Read Full Review »
70
Washington Post: Stephen Hunter
The result is a big, gushy, emotional, secret-driven, family-obsessive casserole, perhaps facile in some of its resolutions, but so full of good heart and love -- the real kind, which is scratchy, awkward, difficult to express and doesn't conquer all but just some -- that the movie is difficult to resist.Read Full Review »
63
USA Today: Claudia Puig
Enjoyable enough. Though like some holiday fare, it doesn't quite stay with you.Read Full Review »
63
Boston Globe: Wesley Morris
One of those overstaffed, overstuffed "when do we eat?" holiday dramedies. Call it a double-extra-strength episode of "Soul Food."Read Full Review »
60
The New York Times: Laura Kern
Boisterous and bittersweet, the film is not dull, but it does feel hopelessly overstuffed, with scant time to devote to any one story line.Read Full Review »
40
Village Voice: Aaron Hillis
The cast has spirit, but the dialogue and situations are phonier than the Yule log on TV.Read Full Review »
See all This Christmas reviews at metacritic.com »