The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada

:

Critics' Reviews

Metascore
®
77
Generally favorable reviews
out of 100
Jones Delivers With 'Three Burials'
By Christy Lemire, Associated Press

Tommy Lee Jones brings his same dry manner and sly humor in front of the camera to his feature debut behind it as director of "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada."

Jones also costars in this spare, old-school Western as a Texas rancher investigating the killing of one of his employees (Julio Cesar Cedillo), an illegal immigrant from Mexico with whom he'd formed an unexpected bond and whose friendship inspires his vengeful trek across the Rio Grande.

Working from a screenplay by Guillermo Arriaga, whose nonlinear narrative recalls his earlier scripts for "Amores Perros" and "21 Grams," Jones lulls us in with wide-screen, scrub-brushed vistas (some of which were shot on his own ranch) and the quirky rhythms of small-town life before reaching his destination with a surprisingly intense, satisfying climax.

Until then, "Three Burials" is all about killing time — in simple, often absurd ways, out in the middle of nowhere.

As a new border patrol agent, watching for Mexicans to cross in groups from their own vast, dry nothingness into more of the same in the United States, Barry Pepper's Mike Norton spends his days flipping through the pages of a Hustler magazine. And waiting.

His tackily gorgeous, bored wife, Lou Ann (January Jones), spends her days chain-smoking at the local truck stop diner and dreaming of going shopping at the mall in faraway Odessa.

Rachel (Melissa Leo), a longtime waitress at the diner, alleviates her own boredom by dallying with both Jones' character, Pete Perkins, and the sheriff (Dwight Yoakam, a perfect jerk here as he was in "Sling Blade") — even though she's married.

The fatal shooting and hasty burial of Melquiades, told in flashbacks and from different perspectives, shakes up all their lives. It also sheds light on who this quiet, polite man was — besides just "a good Mexican," as one clueless cop describes him — and causes the ornery, slightly insane Pete to realize who he's capable of being.

His promise to Melquiades that he'd bury his friend in his tiny, remote hometown if he died takes him on an arduous horseback journey over many miles of steep, ruggedly beautiful terrain (shot with gritty realism by Oscar-winning cinematographer Chris Menges). The strangers he meets along his "Odyssey"-like adventure show him unexpected kindnesses on both sides of the border (and Pete is much more agreeable in Spanish than he is in English).

But he's not alone. Having determined the identity of Melquiades' killer, Pete drags him along for the ride (literally) by beating him up, handcuffing him and strapping him onto the horse behind him. Their trip is often painful to watch — partly because of the languid pacing but mostly because of Pete's bloodily abusive manner in teaching this remorseless killer a lesson.

In classic Western tradition, justice and redemption come as the days and miles pass. And with time and travel, Jones proves he's a director of understated skill and unexpected romanticism. Pete's loyalty to Melquiades and the revelations of his journey stir something deep within him — and in us.

Tommy Lee Jones brings his same dry manner and sly humor in front of the camera to his feature debut behind it as director of "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada."

Jones also costars in this spare, old-school Western as a Texas rancher investigating the killing of one of his employees (Julio Cesar Cedillo), an illegal immigrant from Mexico with whom he'd formed an unexpected bond and whose friendship inspires his vengeful trek across the Rio Grande.

Working from a screenplay by Guillermo Arriaga, whose nonlinear narrative recalls his earlier scripts for "Amores Perros" and "21 Grams," Jones lulls us in with wide-screen, scrub-brushed vistas (some of which were shot on his own ranch) and the quirky rhythms of small-town life before reaching his destination with a surprisingly intense, satisfying climax.

Until then, "Three Burials" is all about killing time — in simple, often absurd ways, out in the middle of nowhere.

As a new border patrol agent, watching for Mexicans to cross in groups from their own vast, dry nothingness into more of the same in the United States, Barry Pepper's Mike Norton spends his days flipping through the pages of a Hustler magazine. And waiting.

His tackily gorgeous, bored wife, Lou Ann (January Jones), spends her days chain-smoking at the local truck stop diner and dreaming of going shopping at the mall in faraway Odessa.

Rachel (Melissa Leo), a longtime waitress at the diner, alleviates her own boredom by dallying with both Jones' character, Pete Perkins, and the sheriff (Dwight Yoakam, a perfect jerk here as he was in "Sling Blade") — even though she's married.

The fatal shooting and hasty burial of Melquiades, told in flashbacks and from different perspectives, shakes up all their lives. It also sheds light on who this quiet, polite man was — besides just "a good Mexican," as one clueless cop describes him — and causes the ornery, slightly insane Pete to realize who he's capable of being.

His promise to Melquiades that he'd bury his friend in his tiny, remote hometown if he died takes him on an arduous horseback journey over many miles of steep, ruggedly beautiful terrain (shot with gritty realism by Oscar-winning cinematographer Chris Menges). The strangers he meets along his "Odyssey"-like adventure show him unexpected kindnesses on both sides of the border (and Pete is much more agreeable in Spanish than he is in English).

But he's not alone. Having determined the identity of Melquiades' killer, Pete drags him along for the ride (literally) by beating him up, handcuffing him and strapping him onto the horse behind him. Their trip is often painful to watch — partly because of the languid pacing but mostly because of Pete's bloodily abusive manner in teaching this remorseless killer a lesson.

In classic Western tradition, justice and redemption come as the days and miles pass. And with time and travel, Jones proves he's a director of understated skill and unexpected romanticism. Pete's loyalty to Melquiades and the revelations of his journey stir something deep within him — and in us.

100
Philadelphia Inquirer: Steven Rea
Wily, sad, funny, and full of life.Read Full Review »
100
LOS ANGELES TIMES: Kevin Thomas
Incisive yet supple, wrenching yet deeply pleasurable, The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada easily ranks among the year's best pictures.Read Full Review »
100
CHICAGO SUN-TIMES: Roger Ebert
In an era when hundreds of lives are casually destroyed in action movies, here is an entire film in which one life is honored, and one death is avenged.Read Full Review »
90
Washington Post: Stephen Hunter
There are complications, extremely cleverly worked out. Jones is in just about every scene in this taut, provocative film.Read Full Review »
88
Boston Globe: Ty Burr
Tommy Lee Jones makes his feature directing debut here, and the film is as weathered, subtle, and sympathetic as the actor's own face.Read Full Review »
88
ROLLING STONE: Peter Travers
Sam Peckinpah lives! The rampaging spirit of the late filmmaker, known as Bloody Sam for films such as "The Wild Bunch" and "Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia," is all over this blistering modern Western from first-time director Tommy Lee Jones.Read Full Review »
80
Salon.com: Andrew O'Hehir
If The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada has some languid patches, it's also a work of uncommon maturity and remarkable poetry.Read Full Review »
80
The New York Times: Manohla Dargis
In a film filled with plaintively expressive faces, characters say as much when they don't talk as when they speak Mr. Arriaga's dialogue, which sometimes sounds like hardscrabble poetry, sometimes sounds real as dirt and is, rather surprisingly, often darkly funny.Read Full Review »
70
Village Voice: Michael Atkinson
Arriaga's script (a prize at Cannes) has a lovely, fascinating shape to it, even if his crushing portrayal of white Americans--all of them, even Jones, suffering from a zombified affect and crippling shortsightedness--is somewhat counterset against his Mexicans, who are all morally balanced, if not always happy or nice.Read Full Review »
60
Time: Richard Schickel
The film comes uncomfortably close to risible. But it also achieves moments of real power. It's worth a wary look before it attains midnight cult-movie status.Read Full Review »
See all The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada reviews at metacritic.com »