Talk to Me

:

Critics' Reviews

Metascore
®
69
Generally favorable reviews
out of 100
'Talk to Me' a Summer Special
By John Hartl, Film critic, MSNBC

"Talk to Me," Kasi Lemmons' engrossing double biography, is a showcase for two fine actors who get a rare chance to strut their versatility.

Don Cheadle, far from the heroics of "Hotel Rwanda," plays Ralph Waldo "Petey" Greene Jr., a pushy, alcoholic, unpredictable ex-convict who became a talk-radio phenomenon in the late 1960s. On the day Martin Luther King died, he provided a much-needed voice of reason for the black community.

Chiwetel Ejiofor, best-known for his work in "Dirty Pretty Things," plays Dewey Hughes, a Washington, D.C., radio executive who recognizes Greene's talent and risks his own job because he fears that WOL-AM will otherwise become identified with the Establishment.

His boss (Martin Sheen) isn't so sure, and Hughes demonstrates his daring by locking him in his office while Greene's broadcast plays live on the air. It's a close call, but when the switchboard starts lighting up in response to Greene's attempts to make it real, a new radio star is born.

The relationship between the proper Hughes and the irrepressible Greene, which makes neither of them look like a pushover, is the heart of "Talk to Me." In perhaps the key episode, a pool game reveals how different they are, and how much they complement each other.

"I need you to say all the things that I'm afraid to say," says Hughes.

Opposites attract, with a vengeance. Greene calls Hughes "another white boy with a tan," and expresses his contempt for Sidney Poitier's "Mr. Tibbs," the straight-talking detective Poitier played in three movies. Hughes puts Greene in his place by demonstrating his pool expertise and proving that he can spout street talk with the best of them.

The competitive chemistry is undeniable, and it continues through the years, right up to the moment Greene blows his big moment on Johnny Carson's show -- and Hughes punches him for giving up on what was really Hughes' childhood dream.

Cheadle takes over the movie almost from the beginning, with a prison scene in which Greene talks a convict out of a confrontation with a warden who is ready to kill. Instantly demonstrating Greene's gift of gab as well as his judgment and timing, Cheadle delivers a performance not quite like anything he has done before.

He's especially good at demonstrating Greene's boldness in his early broadcasts, slyly insulting Berry Gordy on the air, then apologizing without really apologizing. He's even looser in front of a live audience, unconstrained by his radio boss' insistence that "we have to be respectable."

But Greene wouldn't have the opportunity to be Greene if Hughes didn't pave the way, and Ejiofor matches Cheadle's brilliance with a slow-burn performance suggests that Hughes is the one who truly grows and changes. When they're together on-screen, they seem able to get away with anything, even a dicey episode in which Greene shows up nearly naked at Hughes' apartment.

Hughes' date assumes that the two men are lovers, she splits in a hurry, and Cheadle and Ejiofor turn the episode into the movie's most outrageously comic episode. Putting them together was clearly an inspiration, and director Lemmons ("Eve's Bayou") knows exactly what to do with the opportunity.

More movies on MSNBC 

"Talk to Me," Kasi Lemmons' engrossing double biography, is a showcase for two fine actors who get a rare chance to strut their versatility.

Don Cheadle, far from the heroics of "Hotel Rwanda," plays Ralph Waldo "Petey" Greene Jr., a pushy, alcoholic, unpredictable ex-convict who became a talk-radio phenomenon in the late 1960s. On the day Martin Luther King died, he provided a much-needed voice of reason for the black community.

Chiwetel Ejiofor, best-known for his work in "Dirty Pretty Things," plays Dewey Hughes, a Washington, D.C., radio executive who recognizes Greene's talent and risks his own job because he fears that WOL-AM will otherwise become identified with the Establishment.

His boss (Martin Sheen) isn't so sure, and Hughes demonstrates his daring by locking him in his office while Greene's broadcast plays live on the air. It's a close call, but when the switchboard starts lighting up in response to Greene's attempts to make it real, a new radio star is born.

The relationship between the proper Hughes and the irrepressible Greene, which makes neither of them look like a pushover, is the heart of "Talk to Me." In perhaps the key episode, a pool game reveals how different they are, and how much they complement each other.

"I need you to say all the things that I'm afraid to say," says Hughes.

Opposites attract, with a vengeance. Greene calls Hughes "another white boy with a tan," and expresses his contempt for Sidney Poitier's "Mr. Tibbs," the straight-talking detective Poitier played in three movies. Hughes puts Greene in his place by demonstrating his pool expertise and proving that he can spout street talk with the best of them.

The competitive chemistry is undeniable, and it continues through the years, right up to the moment Greene blows his big moment on Johnny Carson's show -- and Hughes punches him for giving up on what was really Hughes' childhood dream.

Cheadle takes over the movie almost from the beginning, with a prison scene in which Greene talks a convict out of a confrontation with a warden who is ready to kill. Instantly demonstrating Greene's gift of gab as well as his judgment and timing, Cheadle delivers a performance not quite like anything he has done before.

He's especially good at demonstrating Greene's boldness in his early broadcasts, slyly insulting Berry Gordy on the air, then apologizing without really apologizing. He's even looser in front of a live audience, unconstrained by his radio boss' insistence that "we have to be respectable."

But Greene wouldn't have the opportunity to be Greene if Hughes didn't pave the way, and Ejiofor matches Cheadle's brilliance with a slow-burn performance suggests that Hughes is the one who truly grows and changes. When they're together on-screen, they seem able to get away with anything, even a dicey episode in which Greene shows up nearly naked at Hughes' apartment.

Hughes' date assumes that the two men are lovers, she splits in a hurry, and Cheadle and Ejiofor turn the episode into the movie's most outrageously comic episode. Putting them together was clearly an inspiration, and director Lemmons ("Eve's Bayou") knows exactly what to do with the opportunity.

More movies on MSNBC 

91
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Owen Gleiberman
A rowdy, richly offbeat biopic.Read Full Review »
88
CHICAGO SUN-TIMES: Roger Ebert
Someone like Petey Greene made a difference and made a mark, and broadcasting is better because of his transparent honesty. He helped transform African-American stations more, probably, than their mostly white owners desired. And talk talents like Howard Stern, whether they know who he was, owe him something.Read Full Review »
88
Philadelphia Inquirer: Carrie Rickey
As Greene, Don Cheadle - explosive because you've never before seen this model of actorly restraint - is a one-man fireworks show in Talk to Me, Kasi Lemmons' rollicking, resonant portrait of the real-life ex-con who improbably became a civic icon.Read Full Review »
80
Time: Richard Schickel
Eventually you may come to think of Talk to Me as a true movie rarity -- a very honest yet curiously affecting experience.Read Full Review »
80
The New York Times: A.O. Scott
The result is a movie that offers uplift without phoniness, history without undue didacticism and a fair number of funny, dirty jokes.Read Full Review »
80
NewsWeek: David Ansen
A vital entertainment that struts confidently between comedy and drama.Read Full Review »
75
Boston Globe: Ty Burr
Especially wonderful is Taraji P. Henson as Petey's longtime girlfriend Vernell , a vision in Foxy Brown period clothes with a pixie smile, lollipop legs, and a filthy mouth. After "Hustle & Flow ," this is at least the second movie Henson has stolen, and will Hollywood please do something about it?Read Full Review »
75
USA Today: Claudia Puig
Talk to Me speaks powerfully to audiences with its potent blend of extraordinary performances and engaging soundtrack.Read Full Review »
70
Salon.com: Stephanie Zacharek
An imperfect picture that's alive every minute, a movie that perfectly captures the vibe of a person, a place, a time and a way of being, and even gets, indirectly and without a whiff of sanctimoniousness, to the heart of what being an American ought to mean.Read Full Review »
70
Washington Post: Stephen Hunter
Talk to Me, with two great actors, tells that story, and it makes you feel not only the joy people experienced in the wash of Greene's raucous, truth-saying humor, but also his wisdom and calm. And many mourned his death at 55 in 1984.Read Full Review »
See all Talk to Me reviews at metacritic.com »