Take the Lead

:

Critics' Reviews

advertisement
Metascore
®
55
Mixed or Average Reviews
out of 100
'Take the Lead': This Dance Is Familiar
By John Hartl, film critic, MSNBC

Antonio Banderas and Alfre Woodard certainly know how to make an entrance.

In the predictable, well-meaning high-school drama "Take the Lead," Banderas is introduced dancing to "Moon River," and he makes both the song and the dance feel fresh. Woodard plays a sardonic, fast-talking New York principal who at first seems cynical about her job — until you realize that she remembers the name of every kid who attends her rowdy school.

Banderas and Woodard walk off with the movie, even though it's supposed to be about the kids they're transforming through ballroom dancing. Yes, ballroom dancing. If that sounds familiar, you probably saw last year's engaging documentary, "Mad Hot Ballroom," which told much the same story, though not as slickly and not as obviously.

"Take the Lead" is based on the true story of Pierre Dulaine, a Manhattan dance teacher (played by Banderas) who volunteered his time to teach ballroom dancing to inner-city high-school kids who had been raised on hip-hop.

In the funniest scene, the kids are horrified as he plays a Gershwin tune, "They Can't Take That Away from Me," and suggests they dance to it. They can't grasp the utterly foreign concept that he actually likes this kind of music. Later he uses the even more alien but equally danceable song, "Fascination," to force them to reach out to another culture.

Woodard's wily administrator, Augustine James, has an equally uphill battle, as she tries to get at least a few of her kids to graduate before they're wiped out by gang warfare. In her sparsely decorated office, she displays pictures of all her kids, promising and otherwise, who became victims of street violence.

Written by Dianne Houston and directed by music-video veteran Liz Friedlander, the movie does a vivid job of setting up the obstacles to Dulaine and James' success, but it's much less convincing when they begin to achieve some progress. The kids give in too quickly to Gershwin and Mancini, and they're too easily rescued from their home lives with drunken fathers and promiscuous mothers.

Dulaine acted as a dance consultant on the movie, yet it feels much less genuine than "Mad Hot Ballroom," which presented the dancers as taking (almost literal) baby steps toward their goals. The young actors in "Take the Lead" don't seem all that young, and when they succeed in competition, they look a lot like adults.

Several of their stories cry out for more development: the homely girl who wants to dance just well enough to satisfy her parents; the destructive, peer-influenced kid who goes home every night to an abusive father; the studious girl who has to fight off her mother's tricks; the sweet fat kid who finally achieves some grace as a dancer.

But Friedlander's choppy editing and Houston's occasionally dopey dialogue ("When I'm dancing I'm in my moment") undercut the work of much of the cast. Only Banderas and Woodard really stand out. Their star power makes "Take the Lead" watchable if never essential.

More movies on MSNBC 

Antonio Banderas and Alfre Woodard certainly know how to make an entrance.

In the predictable, well-meaning high-school drama "Take the Lead," Banderas is introduced dancing to "Moon River," and he makes both the song and the dance feel fresh. Woodard plays a sardonic, fast-talking New York principal who at first seems cynical about her job — until you realize that she remembers the name of every kid who attends her rowdy school.

Banderas and Woodard walk off with the movie, even though it's supposed to be about the kids they're transforming through ballroom dancing. Yes, ballroom dancing. If that sounds familiar, you probably saw last year's engaging documentary, "Mad Hot Ballroom," which told much the same story, though not as slickly and not as obviously.

"Take the Lead" is based on the true story of Pierre Dulaine, a Manhattan dance teacher (played by Banderas) who volunteered his time to teach ballroom dancing to inner-city high-school kids who had been raised on hip-hop.

In the funniest scene, the kids are horrified as he plays a Gershwin tune, "They Can't Take That Away from Me," and suggests they dance to it. They can't grasp the utterly foreign concept that he actually likes this kind of music. Later he uses the even more alien but equally danceable song, "Fascination," to force them to reach out to another culture.

Woodard's wily administrator, Augustine James, has an equally uphill battle, as she tries to get at least a few of her kids to graduate before they're wiped out by gang warfare. In her sparsely decorated office, she displays pictures of all her kids, promising and otherwise, who became victims of street violence.

Written by Dianne Houston and directed by music-video veteran Liz Friedlander, the movie does a vivid job of setting up the obstacles to Dulaine and James' success, but it's much less convincing when they begin to achieve some progress. The kids give in too quickly to Gershwin and Mancini, and they're too easily rescued from their home lives with drunken fathers and promiscuous mothers.

Dulaine acted as a dance consultant on the movie, yet it feels much less genuine than "Mad Hot Ballroom," which presented the dancers as taking (almost literal) baby steps toward their goals. The young actors in "Take the Lead" don't seem all that young, and when they succeed in competition, they look a lot like adults.

Several of their stories cry out for more development: the homely girl who wants to dance just well enough to satisfy her parents; the destructive, peer-influenced kid who goes home every night to an abusive father; the studious girl who has to fight off her mother's tricks; the sweet fat kid who finally achieves some grace as a dancer.

But Friedlander's choppy editing and Houston's occasionally dopey dialogue ("When I'm dancing I'm in my moment") undercut the work of much of the cast. Only Banderas and Woodard really stand out. Their star power makes "Take the Lead" watchable if never essential.

More movies on MSNBC 

75
CHICAGO SUN-TIMES: Roger Ebert
Antonio Banderas is reason enough to see the movie.Read Full Review »
70
Salon.com: Stephanie Zacharek
Its considerable charm lies in the way it fulfills, rather than bucks, our expectations.Read Full Review »
63
ROLLING STONE: Peter Travers
Inspired by a true story (translation: a lot of it is made up), the movie shucks its corn straight from the cob. But it's no less engaging for that, thanks to the enthusiasm of the young cast and the fusion of classic dance with hip-hop moves courtesy of Rich and Tone Talauega.Read Full Review »
63
Philadelphia Inquirer: Carrie Rickey
At one point, Dulaine takes the students to his studio and they look up at the mirrored disco ball glittering above the dance floor. "Corny, but cool," says one of the sweathogs. My feelings about the film precisely.Read Full Review »
63
USA Today: Claudia Puig
The movie's best moments are between Banderas and the kids. When the plot shifts to reveal the students' back stories (one has a prostitute mother, another a drunken father), the story becomes a melodramatic rehash of other movies, like "Fame" or "Rent."Read Full Review »
60
Village Voice: Luke Y. Thompson
It's no surprise to anyone who's seen his Robert Rodriguez films that Banderas works well with kids. But it may surprise those who saw "Evita" that he can make a music-and-dance movie that doesn't suck.Read Full Review »
50
Boston Globe: Wesley Morris
The movie partners all the cliches of the inner-city school drama with the cliches of the dance instructional, and the two keep stomping on each other's toes.Read Full Review »
50
The New York Times: Stephen Holden
Take the Lead, despite its nifty concept and fiery leading man, feels sloppy and rushed.Read Full Review »
50
ReelViews: James Berardinelli
One of the year's most uninspired inspirational stories.Read Full Review »
40
Washington Post: Sarah Kaufman
The young cast members are full of attitude and heart. But the film is long on flashy dance sequences and short on depth, character and craft.Read Full Review »
See all Take the Lead reviews at metacritic.com »