Bing Search

Stay Alive

:

Critics' Reviews

Our critic says...
Metascore
®
24
Generally Unfavorable Reviews
out of 100
Stay Away from 'Stay Alive'
By Christy Lemire, Associated Press

In "Stay Alive," if you die in the video game, you die in real life.

This is a cool/potentially creepy idea only if, like, you're in high school and goofing around with your friends at the movie theater on a Friday (as many were during a recent matinee, which this critic had to attend because the film wasn't screened before opening).

For everyone else, this isn't just a preposterous premise for a horror movie, it's a source of unintentional hilarity.

"Somebody ran my brother down in a horse-drawn carriage!" yells goth-chick October (Sophia Bush), one of many characters with distractingly unusual names. Because, you know, that's what happened to her brother Phineus while he was playing the video game — titled, appropriately enough, "Stay Alive."

Meanwhile, "Malcolm in the Middle" star Frankie Muniz, slumming as a hyperactive gaming geek named Swink Sylvania, screams out as things get ugly, "Something's happening! Something bad!" and sounding as if he's paraphrasing a song from "West Side Story."

Recycling ideas from "The Lawnmower Man," the "Final Destination" movies, the third "Spy Kids" and "Tron," "Stay Alive," features an underground video game that a bunch of pretty teenagers feel compelled to play because it was the last thing one of their friends was doing before he died. A loving tribute, indeed.

The game has something to do with a Louisiana plantation-turned-finishing school, where a bunch of little girls were brutally killed and now scamper about as the undead. As the player, you have to track down and destroy the source of evil, some 17th century noblewoman known as The Blood Countess.

After sitting around talking trash and getting carpal tunnel syndrome, the gamers (including Jon Foster, Samaire Armstrong and Adam Goldberg, who's fallen far from "Saving Private Ryan") eventually realize that the characters on screen look just like them, and that "Stay Alive" is making them see and hear things even after they've stopped playing.

Then when they begin dropping one by one in exactly the manner they die on screen, they get even more freaked out.

Dude!

But the effects in the movie from director William Brent Bell, who co-wrote the script with Matthew Peterman, look too jumpy and cheesy to make anyone in the audience seriously squirm.

It's enough to make last year's video game-inspired "Alone in the Dark," starring Tara Reid as a brilliant anthropologist, look better all the time.

In "Stay Alive," if you die in the video game, you die in real life.

This is a cool/potentially creepy idea only if, like, you're in high school and goofing around with your friends at the movie theater on a Friday (as many were during a recent matinee, which this critic had to attend because the film wasn't screened before opening).

For everyone else, this isn't just a preposterous premise for a horror movie, it's a source of unintentional hilarity.

"Somebody ran my brother down in a horse-drawn carriage!" yells goth-chick October (Sophia Bush), one of many characters with distractingly unusual names. Because, you know, that's what happened to her brother Phineus while he was playing the video game — titled, appropriately enough, "Stay Alive."

Meanwhile, "Malcolm in the Middle" star Frankie Muniz, slumming as a hyperactive gaming geek named Swink Sylvania, screams out as things get ugly, "Something's happening! Something bad!" and sounding as if he's paraphrasing a song from "West Side Story."

Recycling ideas from "The Lawnmower Man," the "Final Destination" movies, the third "Spy Kids" and "Tron," "Stay Alive," features an underground video game that a bunch of pretty teenagers feel compelled to play because it was the last thing one of their friends was doing before he died. A loving tribute, indeed.

The game has something to do with a Louisiana plantation-turned-finishing school, where a bunch of little girls were brutally killed and now scamper about as the undead. As the player, you have to track down and destroy the source of evil, some 17th century noblewoman known as The Blood Countess.

After sitting around talking trash and getting carpal tunnel syndrome, the gamers (including Jon Foster, Samaire Armstrong and Adam Goldberg, who's fallen far from "Saving Private Ryan") eventually realize that the characters on screen look just like them, and that "Stay Alive" is making them see and hear things even after they've stopped playing.

Then when they begin dropping one by one in exactly the manner they die on screen, they get even more freaked out.

Dude!

But the effects in the movie from director William Brent Bell, who co-wrote the script with Matthew Peterman, look too jumpy and cheesy to make anyone in the audience seriously squirm.

It's enough to make last year's video game-inspired "Alone in the Dark," starring Tara Reid as a brilliant anthropologist, look better all the time.

50
Variety: 

Despite some hackneyed qualities, helmer William Brent Bell's good-looking if undistinguished cast and the seemingly fresh twist on an old tale should lure the usual fans of mayhem, murder and the medieval.

Read Full Review »
50
TV GUIDE: Maitland McDonagh

Horror buffs looking for a novel twist on genre formulas should look elsewhere, but this body-count potboiler about a sinister video game and the poor dopes who make the mistake of playing it is the movie equivalent of junk food: It's not good, but it's predictable and even satisfying, in a low-expectations way.

Read Full Review »
40
LOS ANGELES TIMES: John Anderson

Stay Alive spends a lot of time inside the video game system, and what will terrify the audience very early on is the realization that there's better acting in the video game than on the big screen.

Read Full Review »
40
LOS ANGELES TIMES: John Anderson

Stay Alive spends a lot of time inside the video game system, and what will terrify the audience very early on is the realization that there's better acting in the video game than on the big screen.

Read Full Review »
40
The New York Times: Neil Genzlinger

The star of Stay Alive is a cutting-edge video game, but the film still has hackneyed horror at its heart. And worse, it's not even the stylishly, wittily executed hackneyed horror of the "Scream" movies.

Read Full Review »
40
The New York Times: 

The star of Stay Alive is a cutting-edge video game, but the film still has hackneyed horror at its heart. And worse, it's not even the stylishly, wittily executed hackneyed horror of the "Scream" movies.

Read Full Review »
38
NEW YORK DAILY NEWS: Elizabeth Weitzman

There's a fascinating and terrifying story to be told about Elizabeth Bathory, the dramatically depraved 17th century sadist known as the Blood Countess.....This ain't it.

Read Full Review »
38
Boston Globe: James Parker

Always the way in horror flicks: These first scenes, when the characters are being tenderly established and the concept is still young, are the best.

Read Full Review »
38
Boston Globe: 

Always the way in horror flicks: These first scenes, when the characters are being tenderly established and the concept is still young, are the best.

Read Full Review »
25
SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE: 

Works better as unintentional comedy than horror.

Read Full Review »
See all Stay Alive reviews at metacritic.com »
showtimes & tickets
Search by location, title, or genre:
upcoming movies on
featured video