Scary Movie 4

:

Critics' Reviews

advertisement
Metascore
®
40
Mixed or Average Reviews
out of 100
'Scary Movie 4' Is Just More of the Same
By Christy Lemire, Associated Press

The makers of "Airplane!" have reconnected for "Scary Movie 4," but they've created a sequel that never truly takes flight.

Then again, director David Zucker and writer Jim Abrahams didn't really have anywhere to go.

As in the first three installments of this insanely successful franchise, the formula remains the same. Make fun of a bunch of movies (whether they're scary or not is irrelevant). Throw in some pop culture references, a couple of political jabs and a few rappers, just because they appeal to the films' young target audience. (This time you get Chingy, Fabolous and Lil Jon!)

Finally, sprinkle liberally with gross bodily noises and fluids, mix it up, throw it at the wall in one steaming, gloppy wad and see what sticks.

Very little, as you might expect.

Along with co-writer Craig Mazin, who also collaborated with Zucker on "Scary Movie 3," they've come up with a film that shows sporadic flashes of comic greatness, separated by draggy repetitive stretches that make "Scary Movie 4" feel longer than its 83-minute running time. That number includes the closing credits, by the way, and we're talking about a cast of thousands — everyone from Dr. Phil to Shaquille O'Neal.

Those two get things off to a strong start in a spoof of "Saw," in which both are chained to a device connected to a basketball net, and all Shaq has to do is make a free throw to unleash them — something the Miami Heat center has a hard time sinking under optimal circumstances. And here, the ball is literally a rock. But hey, at least he can laugh at himself.

From there, it's a cross between a parody of the Japanese horror remake "The Grudge," featuring longtime "Scary Movie" star Anna Faris in the Sarah Michelle Gellar role, and "War of the Worlds," with Craig Bierko filling in for Tom Cruise. Faris' Cindy Campbell sees visions of a spooky dead child while housesitting for a catatonic elderly woman (Cloris Leachman, who gets the pleasure of a sponge bath with a liquid that's not water); meanwhile, Bierko's Tom Ryan tries desperately to bond with the kids who hate him while aliens tromp across New York.

Give the "Scary Movie" movies credit for one thing: They get the details perfectly, right down to the costumes and camera angles. But it's like watching an episode of "Saturday Night Live" on the big screen. The gags are hit-and-miss, and regardless of their success, they categorically go on too long.

A "Brokeback Mountain" spoof involving a couple of cowboys who are black and gay is delightfully twisted at first  — it features petroleum jelly, rubber gloves and a disco ball while they serenade each other in a tent with Lionel Richie's "Hello" — but it doesn't know when to end. Same with a sight gag involving a suicidal Charlie Sheen, whose character accidentally overdoses on Viagra.

And while the idea of Carmen Electra playing the blind young woman in "The Village" is funny, the sight of her stripping down to a corset, stockings and heels and very loudly relieving herself in front of the townsfolk isn't.

Regardless of what Zucker and Abrahams do, they never achieve the extended, silly thrill of "Airplane!" — the 1980 movie that made it easy to surrender to your inner 12-year-old boy. Maybe it's just that the idea of being so goofy and politically incorrect isn't quite so novel anymore; it's been done, ad nauseam. And maybe it's just that the source material for the "Scary Movie" movies keeps getting weaker.

They closest they come is a scene in which Cindy and the creepy kid are speaking to each other in subtitled Japanese, but all they're saying is words like Mitsubishi, Sony and sushi.

It's not as daring as, "Stewardess? I speak jive." But it comes closer than anything else.

The makers of "Airplane!" have reconnected for "Scary Movie 4," but they've created a sequel that never truly takes flight.

Then again, director David Zucker and writer Jim Abrahams didn't really have anywhere to go.

As in the first three installments of this insanely successful franchise, the formula remains the same. Make fun of a bunch of movies (whether they're scary or not is irrelevant). Throw in some pop culture references, a couple of political jabs and a few rappers, just because they appeal to the films' young target audience. (This time you get Chingy, Fabolous and Lil Jon!)

Finally, sprinkle liberally with gross bodily noises and fluids, mix it up, throw it at the wall in one steaming, gloppy wad and see what sticks.

Very little, as you might expect.

Along with co-writer Craig Mazin, who also collaborated with Zucker on "Scary Movie 3," they've come up with a film that shows sporadic flashes of comic greatness, separated by draggy repetitive stretches that make "Scary Movie 4" feel longer than its 83-minute running time. That number includes the closing credits, by the way, and we're talking about a cast of thousands — everyone from Dr. Phil to Shaquille O'Neal.

Those two get things off to a strong start in a spoof of "Saw," in which both are chained to a device connected to a basketball net, and all Shaq has to do is make a free throw to unleash them — something the Miami Heat center has a hard time sinking under optimal circumstances. And here, the ball is literally a rock. But hey, at least he can laugh at himself.

From there, it's a cross between a parody of the Japanese horror remake "The Grudge," featuring longtime "Scary Movie" star Anna Faris in the Sarah Michelle Gellar role, and "War of the Worlds," with Craig Bierko filling in for Tom Cruise. Faris' Cindy Campbell sees visions of a spooky dead child while housesitting for a catatonic elderly woman (Cloris Leachman, who gets the pleasure of a sponge bath with a liquid that's not water); meanwhile, Bierko's Tom Ryan tries desperately to bond with the kids who hate him while aliens tromp across New York.

Give the "Scary Movie" movies credit for one thing: They get the details perfectly, right down to the costumes and camera angles. But it's like watching an episode of "Saturday Night Live" on the big screen. The gags are hit-and-miss, and regardless of their success, they categorically go on too long.

A "Brokeback Mountain" spoof involving a couple of cowboys who are black and gay is delightfully twisted at first  — it features petroleum jelly, rubber gloves and a disco ball while they serenade each other in a tent with Lionel Richie's "Hello" — but it doesn't know when to end. Same with a sight gag involving a suicidal Charlie Sheen, whose character accidentally overdoses on Viagra.

And while the idea of Carmen Electra playing the blind young woman in "The Village" is funny, the sight of her stripping down to a corset, stockings and heels and very loudly relieving herself in front of the townsfolk isn't.

Regardless of what Zucker and Abrahams do, they never achieve the extended, silly thrill of "Airplane!" — the 1980 movie that made it easy to surrender to your inner 12-year-old boy. Maybe it's just that the idea of being so goofy and politically incorrect isn't quite so novel anymore; it's been done, ad nauseam. And maybe it's just that the source material for the "Scary Movie" movies keeps getting weaker.

They closest they come is a scene in which Cindy and the creepy kid are speaking to each other in subtitled Japanese, but all they're saying is words like Mitsubishi, Sony and sushi.

It's not as daring as, "Stewardess? I speak jive." But it comes closer than anything else.

58
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Lisa Schwarzbaum
And as ever, the jokes are a jumble of the gross, the baggy, the raunchy, the mistimed, and - every once in a while - the refreshingly incorrect.Read Full Review »
50
ReelViews: James Berardinelli
To go with the good, there's plenty of bad, and it comes in the form of countless gags that misfire, far too much flatulence and urine, and (God help us) a buck naked Leslie Nielsen. Admittedly, that scene certainly puts the "scary" in Scary Movie 4.Read Full Review »
50
The New York Times: Nathan Lee
The fun of Scary Movie 4 is that it isn't a movie at all. Organized on the principle of parody, not plot, driven by gags and cultural feedback, it's an exercise in lowbrow postmodernism, a movie-movie contraption more nuts than Charlie Kaufman's gnarliest fever dream. It's cleverly stupid.Read Full Review »
50
Village Voice: Luke Y. Thompson
The jokes miss more than they hit, but there are a lot of them, and when they work, it's gold.Read Full Review »
50
Philadelphia Inquirer: Steven Rea
Shaquille O'Neal and Dr. Phil open Scary Movie 4 with an achingly unfunny couple of minutes of severed limbs and errant hoop shots.Read Full Review »
30
LOS ANGELES TIMES: Jan Stuart
Isn't it amazing to see just how low some people will stoop if you pay them enough?Read Full Review »
30
Slate: Ben Wasserstein
Jokes from Scary Movie 3 are recycled ad nauseam.Read Full Review »
25
Boston Globe: Wesley Morris
Part sketch-comedy cartoon, part Cracked magazine spoof, installment four is the most scornfully made yet.Read Full Review »
See all Scary Movie 4 reviews at metacritic.com »