Music and Lyrics

:

Critics' Reviews

Metascore
®
59
Mixed or Average Reviews
out of 100
'Music' OK Date Movie for Valentine's Day
By John Hartl, Film critic, MSNBC

For Valentine's Day, you could do a lot worse than "Music and Lyrics," the new Hugh Grant/Drew Barrymore romantic comedy. While it may go soft near the end, when it slavishly adheres to the conventions of the genre, it begins with an irresistible burst of energy and remains quite watchable for much of its running time. And as far as first-run date movies go, it's really the only game in town.

Cast as an aging rock star named Alex Fletcher, Grant delivers one of those wonderfully self-effacing performances that keeps him from going stale. During an exhilarating opening credit sequence that seems designed for an instant replay (it does get a rerun during the closing credits), we see Fletcher in his 1980s glory, churning out glossy boy-band videos that could have been telecast during the first summer of MTV.

But now he's a nostalgia attraction, reduced to playing amusement parks and considering a boxing showdown with another washed-up star in "The Battle of the 1980s Has-Beens." We learn that Adam Ant and Billy Idol have agreed to compete on the show, but Fletcher must draw the line somewhere.

Besides, he's been given an opportunity to work with the current queen of pop, Cora (Haley Bennett), a bubble headed trend-setter who claims that one of his songs made her childhood bearable when her parents were splitting up. She wants him to write and perform a song with her, and she's even given him a title — "A Way Back Into Love" — inspired by her traumatic breakup with a boyfriend who lasted all of two months.

The lyrics are eventually provided by Sophie Fisher (Barrymore), a ditsy motormouth who waters Fletcher's plants and turns out to have other talents. Her older sister (Kristen Johnston), another Fletcher fan, cheers her on when they become an item, while his manager (Brad Garrett) tries to adjust to each new development.

Writer-director Marc Lawrence worked with Sandra Bullock on "Forces of Nature" and the "Miss Congeniality" movies, and he previously directed Bullock and Hugh Grant in "Two Weeks Notice." He keeps trying to create a romantic comedy that won't fizzle out before the final stretch, and this one comes closer than most.

Still, there's no denying that once it gets to the inevitable "boy loses girl" turn in the road, it's fresh out of ideas. Just when the picture seems ready to take off, with Sophie registering a sudden attack of "creative differences" while Cora stages an appallingly pretentious concert, it fails to launch.

Barrymore and Grant do have an easy chemistry that makes their characters' attraction to each other plausible, and Lawrence develops it by emphasizing one especially long take of the couple sparring on a sidewalk.

"I'm a happy has-been," Fletcher declares, and he seems utterly sincere in his adjustment to endless compromises. She pushes him to do more with his life, and that clicks, too. There's a give-and-take between the two, whether they're collaborating on a song or clumsily succumbing to passion, that keeps "Music and Lyrics" from collapsing.

More movies on MSNBC 

For Valentine's Day, you could do a lot worse than "Music and Lyrics," the new Hugh Grant/Drew Barrymore romantic comedy. While it may go soft near the end, when it slavishly adheres to the conventions of the genre, it begins with an irresistible burst of energy and remains quite watchable for much of its running time. And as far as first-run date movies go, it's really the only game in town.

Cast as an aging rock star named Alex Fletcher, Grant delivers one of those wonderfully self-effacing performances that keeps him from going stale. During an exhilarating opening credit sequence that seems designed for an instant replay (it does get a rerun during the closing credits), we see Fletcher in his 1980s glory, churning out glossy boy-band videos that could have been telecast during the first summer of MTV.

But now he's a nostalgia attraction, reduced to playing amusement parks and considering a boxing showdown with another washed-up star in "The Battle of the 1980s Has-Beens." We learn that Adam Ant and Billy Idol have agreed to compete on the show, but Fletcher must draw the line somewhere.

Besides, he's been given an opportunity to work with the current queen of pop, Cora (Haley Bennett), a bubble headed trend-setter who claims that one of his songs made her childhood bearable when her parents were splitting up. She wants him to write and perform a song with her, and she's even given him a title — "A Way Back Into Love" — inspired by her traumatic breakup with a boyfriend who lasted all of two months.

The lyrics are eventually provided by Sophie Fisher (Barrymore), a ditsy motormouth who waters Fletcher's plants and turns out to have other talents. Her older sister (Kristen Johnston), another Fletcher fan, cheers her on when they become an item, while his manager (Brad Garrett) tries to adjust to each new development.

Writer-director Marc Lawrence worked with Sandra Bullock on "Forces of Nature" and the "Miss Congeniality" movies, and he previously directed Bullock and Hugh Grant in "Two Weeks Notice." He keeps trying to create a romantic comedy that won't fizzle out before the final stretch, and this one comes closer than most.

Still, there's no denying that once it gets to the inevitable "boy loses girl" turn in the road, it's fresh out of ideas. Just when the picture seems ready to take off, with Sophie registering a sudden attack of "creative differences" while Cora stages an appallingly pretentious concert, it fails to launch.

Barrymore and Grant do have an easy chemistry that makes their characters' attraction to each other plausible, and Lawrence develops it by emphasizing one especially long take of the couple sparring on a sidewalk.

"I'm a happy has-been," Fletcher declares, and he seems utterly sincere in his adjustment to endless compromises. She pushes him to do more with his life, and that clicks, too. There's a give-and-take between the two, whether they're collaborating on a song or clumsily succumbing to passion, that keeps "Music and Lyrics" from collapsing.

More movies on MSNBC 

75
Philadelphia Inquirer: Carrie Rickey
The two generate more heart than they do heat, but that's the point. You want to see them together not just because they're adorable, but because you believe that their characters can take each other to a place neither could get to on their own.Read Full Review »
75
ReelViews: James Berardinelli
Music and Lyrics is frequently appealing, often witty, and occasionally funny, but it's not going to convert skeptics and cynics into sentimentalists.Read Full Review »
75
USA Today: Claudia Puig
This appealing romantic comedy undertakes the conventions of the formula without an inordinate amount of clichés. Music also infuses the overall plot with a satire of the music industry, and the pop tunes and lyrics are catchy.Read Full Review »
70
Salon.com: Stephanie Zacharek
It may be slight, but it's also buoyant and pleasurable, partly because the leads make the whole thing feel like a spontaneous duet. Lawrence trusts them to carry the picture, without feeling the need to throw in a lot of extraneous fluff.Read Full Review »
70
Washington Post: Stephen Hunter
I don't think the ending is up to the rest of the movie, but Grant and Barrymore are great together, and the movie has both zing and song.Read Full Review »
67
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Lisa Schwarzbaum
Grant is game for a new level of meta-ha-ha, joke's-on-me in Music and Lyrics. But with Drew Barrymore as his costar, this bland, light romantic comedy insists on keeping the commentary as disposable as one of the '80s gumball tunes Grant used to swivel to as Alex Fletcher, a washed-up '80s pop star.Read Full Review »
63
Boston Globe: Ty Burr
In the end, the movie's just the kind of enjoyably empty-headed fluff it celebrates and mocks. It sits up, it begs, eventually it plays dead, and still you want to pat it on the head. It's a good dog.Read Full Review »
60
The New York Times: A.O. Scott
While there is not much chemistry between Mr. Grant and Ms. Barrymore, they are professional enough to work with the movie's conceit while sending flickers of idiosyncratic charm off the screen.Read Full Review »
50
Village Voice: Robert Wilonsky
Music and Lyrics suggests that it's going to be about redemption, the second act in the life of a punchline, but it feels as though it were made to fit a date on a studio's release schedule. (Happy Valentine's Day!) Oh, well, at least the songs are catchy, and the two-tone video for "Pop Goes My Heart" is inspired.Read Full Review »
See all Music and Lyrics reviews at metacritic.com »