Munich

:

Critics' Reviews

Metascore
®
74
Generally favorable reviews
out of 100
'Munich' A Haunted Thriller
By John Hartl, Film critic, MSNBC

"When will it ever end?" asks a worn-out character in "Munich," Steven Spielberg's riveting, thoughtful dramatization of the revenge killings that followed the massacre of 11 Israeli athletes at the 1972 Munich Olympics.

Beginning with television footage of the Olympics, complete with appearances by the young Jim McCay and Peter Jennings, the movie at first seems to be going over the same territory as Kevin Macdonald's Oscar-winning 1999 documentary, "One Day in September."

But it soon switches its focus to a Mossad agent, Avner (Eric Bana), who is recruited to hunt down the killers. At first delighted by his team, which includes a Belgian bomb-maker (Mathieu Kassovitz), a German forger (Hanns Zischler), a merciless South African driver (Daniel Craig) and a more scrupulous clean-up expert (Ciarán Hinds), Avner becomes increasingly haunted by his mission.

It not only takes him away from his wife and child but eventually seems to put them in harm's way as well. Once he's become a part of the cycle of revenge, both aided and possibly targeted by a global network of espionage experts, he seems incapable of finding peace.

The film struggles to find a satisfying ending, partly because there can't be one. What began as a search for justice has been transformed into seemingly unstoppable savagery. Having accomplished only some of what he set out to do, Avner now lives in fear.

Written by Tony Kushner ("Angels in America") and Eric Roth ("Forrest Gump"), the script does a delicate balancing job of presenting Israeli and Palestinian positions. Both sides are passionate about what they regard as their homeland, both are committed to a brutal eye-for-an-eye agenda and both are inevitably compromised by the experience. Spielberg has been criticized for emphasizing the Israelis' side, but in the end there's really no one to root for — which seems to be his point.

With its international cast, atmospheric European locations and attention to pre-assassination detail, the movie often recalls Fred Zinnemann's "The Day of the Jackal." Michel Lonsdale, one of the key actors in that 1973 classic, even turns up in a crucial role, as the head of a Mafia-like family that regards itself as morally superior to "legitimate" governments.

Lonsdale brings a catlike playfulness to this character, who gets a charge out of toying with Avner, who pays him to supply names and whereabouts of the killers. He also teases his own son (Mathieu Amalric), who has clearly inherited his dad's penchant for enigmatic mischief-making.

They provide a welcome light touch in a movie that occasionally threatens to become the kind of cheap horror film in which each fresh victim is killed in a spectacularly different manner. Certainly violence is inherent in the story, but when the filmmakers choose, quite late in the film, to intercut the Munich massacre with a tortured sex scene, they seem to have become momentarily unhinged.

In most other respects, "Munich" demonstrates Spielberg's control of difficult material. The casting is especially impressive, with Craig (the new James Bond), Hinds (Julius Caesar in HBO's "Rome") and Bana (the heroic heart of last year's "Troy") all making essential contributions.

More movies on MSNBC 

"When will it ever end?" asks a worn-out character in "Munich," Steven Spielberg's riveting, thoughtful dramatization of the revenge killings that followed the massacre of 11 Israeli athletes at the 1972 Munich Olympics.

Beginning with television footage of the Olympics, complete with appearances by the young Jim McCay and Peter Jennings, the movie at first seems to be going over the same territory as Kevin Macdonald's Oscar-winning 1999 documentary, "One Day in September."

But it soon switches its focus to a Mossad agent, Avner (Eric Bana), who is recruited to hunt down the killers. At first delighted by his team, which includes a Belgian bomb-maker (Mathieu Kassovitz), a German forger (Hanns Zischler), a merciless South African driver (Daniel Craig) and a more scrupulous clean-up expert (Ciarán Hinds), Avner becomes increasingly haunted by his mission.

It not only takes him away from his wife and child but eventually seems to put them in harm's way as well. Once he's become a part of the cycle of revenge, both aided and possibly targeted by a global network of espionage experts, he seems incapable of finding peace.

The film struggles to find a satisfying ending, partly because there can't be one. What began as a search for justice has been transformed into seemingly unstoppable savagery. Having accomplished only some of what he set out to do, Avner now lives in fear.

Written by Tony Kushner ("Angels in America") and Eric Roth ("Forrest Gump"), the script does a delicate balancing job of presenting Israeli and Palestinian positions. Both sides are passionate about what they regard as their homeland, both are committed to a brutal eye-for-an-eye agenda and both are inevitably compromised by the experience. Spielberg has been criticized for emphasizing the Israelis' side, but in the end there's really no one to root for — which seems to be his point.

With its international cast, atmospheric European locations and attention to pre-assassination detail, the movie often recalls Fred Zinnemann's "The Day of the Jackal." Michel Lonsdale, one of the key actors in that 1973 classic, even turns up in a crucial role, as the head of a Mafia-like family that regards itself as morally superior to "legitimate" governments.

Lonsdale brings a catlike playfulness to this character, who gets a charge out of toying with Avner, who pays him to supply names and whereabouts of the killers. He also teases his own son (Mathieu Amalric), who has clearly inherited his dad's penchant for enigmatic mischief-making.

They provide a welcome light touch in a movie that occasionally threatens to become the kind of cheap horror film in which each fresh victim is killed in a spectacularly different manner. Certainly violence is inherent in the story, but when the filmmakers choose, quite late in the film, to intercut the Munich massacre with a tortured sex scene, they seem to have become momentarily unhinged.

In most other respects, "Munich" demonstrates Spielberg's control of difficult material. The casting is especially impressive, with Craig (the new James Bond), Hinds (Julius Caesar in HBO's "Rome") and Bana (the heroic heart of last year's "Troy") all making essential contributions.

More movies on MSNBC 

100
ReelViews: James Berardinelli
A film of uncommon depth, intelligence, and sensitivity.Read Full Review »
100
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Owen Gleiberman
Munich, Steven Spielberg's spectacularly gripping and unsettling new movie, is a grave and haunted film, yet its power lies in its willingness to be a work of brutal excitement.Read Full Review »
100
NewsWeek: David Ansen
A superbly taut and well-made thriller that jumps from Geneva to Rome, from Paris to Beirut, from Athens to Brooklyn, each lethal assignment staged with a mastery Hitchcock might envy.Read Full Review »
100
CHICAGO SUN-TIMES: Roger Ebert
As a thriller, Munich is efficient, absorbing, effective. As an ethical argument, it is haunting.Read Full Review »
100
Slate: David Edelstein
Munich is the most potent, the most vital, the best movie of the year.Read Full Review »
90
LOS ANGELES TIMES: Kenneth Turan
Munich's even-handed cry for peace is not an act of equivocation but one of bravery. What Munich has to say, and its ability to say it to the widest possible audience, couldn't be more needed than it is right now.Read Full Review »
88
Philadelphia Inquirer: Steven Rea
If Munich raises disturbing issues about Jewish-Arab relations, past and present - and how can it not? - it is also an absolutely riveting tale of the hunt and the hunted.Read Full Review »
88
ROLLING STONE: Peter Travers
Bana is magnificent in the role.Read Full Review »
88
Boston Globe: Ty Burr
The director can work wonders within his celluloid universe, but when the time comes to hand us back to reality, he stumbles. With this movie, that hurts.Read Full Review »
88
USA Today: Mike Clark
This is a smart and often tense work whose ultimate merit isn't completely calculable now.Read Full Review »
See all Munich reviews at metacritic.com »