Glory Road

:

Critics' Reviews

Metascore
®
58
Mixed or Average Reviews
out of 100
'Glory Road' Feels So Familiar
By John Hartl, Film critic, MSNBC

Ben Affleck's loss proves to be Josh Lucas' gain in "Glory Road," a slickly formulaic Disney sports drama in which Lucas ended up replacing Affleck in the starring role. It's the biggest part Lucas has had to date (he was in last summer's "Stealth"), and he instantly owns it.

As the relentless Texas Western basketball coach, Don Haskins, who led the partly African-American Miners team to victory in the mid-1960s, Lucas comes across as a punishing cheerleader, drilling discipline into his handpicked team. Booze, women and late nights are strictly off-limits, and if you don't believe it, Haskins is ready and willing to provide you with a ticket home and a packed suitcase.

In his fierce locker-room pep talks, he cajoles, terrorizes, preaches the virtues of "fundamental basketball," and ultimately wills his team into victory. Lucas does his best to make the character compelling and credible. In a better movie, he might have succeeded.

James Gartner, the first-time director of "Glory Road," isn't content just to tell a story. At the outset, the movie announces that this is "the team that changed everything." Yes, "everything." The closing credits claim that their final upset was the most important event in the history of college basketball.

But in the end their victory is less inspiring than, say, the less-heralded underdog triumph in "Hoosiers," a better basketball movie that doesn't traffic so gleefully in clichés. For one thing, "Hoosiers" doesn't make its women nearly invisible.

Gartner and his writers barely allow Haskins' wife to exist, and the same is true for the other women who briefly turn up. The movie has as little use for them as Haskins does. Whenever Haskins sees one of his players with a woman, he starts ranting about the "nonsense" of romance. When he moves his family into a college dormitory, his wife's confused reaction is barely acknowledged.

For period flavor, Gartner throws Buddy Holly and "The Ballad of the Green Berets" on the soundtrack, but it takes him half the film to discover the subject that is most directly tied to the 1960s: the American apartheid that makes it all but impossible for the team to find lodgings, eat in restaurants and visit a restroom without being beaten.

The chief villain is a racist coach, Adolph Rupp (Jon Voight), whose Kentucky team provides a special challenge to Haskins' boys. Rupp's wife, who carefully announces that she's no bigot, has even less screen time than Haskins' mate.

One of the writers, Gregory Allen Howard, worked on another pair of sports movies, "Ali" and "Remember the Titans," and unfortunately it shows. What the script needs is a writer who can rethink this material, freshen it, refuse to Disneyfy it. But because the producer is Jerry Bruckheimer ("Armageddon," "Bad Boys"), well, that's not going to happen.

"Glory Road" is not without its charms. The locker-room interplay among the teammates has some wit, Derek Luke communicates great charm as the team's star and Lucas fans will be happy to see him taking the leading role for a change.

More movies on MSNBC 

Ben Affleck's loss proves to be Josh Lucas' gain in "Glory Road," a slickly formulaic Disney sports drama in which Lucas ended up replacing Affleck in the starring role. It's the biggest part Lucas has had to date (he was in last summer's "Stealth"), and he instantly owns it.

As the relentless Texas Western basketball coach, Don Haskins, who led the partly African-American Miners team to victory in the mid-1960s, Lucas comes across as a punishing cheerleader, drilling discipline into his handpicked team. Booze, women and late nights are strictly off-limits, and if you don't believe it, Haskins is ready and willing to provide you with a ticket home and a packed suitcase.

In his fierce locker-room pep talks, he cajoles, terrorizes, preaches the virtues of "fundamental basketball," and ultimately wills his team into victory. Lucas does his best to make the character compelling and credible. In a better movie, he might have succeeded.

James Gartner, the first-time director of "Glory Road," isn't content just to tell a story. At the outset, the movie announces that this is "the team that changed everything." Yes, "everything." The closing credits claim that their final upset was the most important event in the history of college basketball.

But in the end their victory is less inspiring than, say, the less-heralded underdog triumph in "Hoosiers," a better basketball movie that doesn't traffic so gleefully in clichés. For one thing, "Hoosiers" doesn't make its women nearly invisible.

Gartner and his writers barely allow Haskins' wife to exist, and the same is true for the other women who briefly turn up. The movie has as little use for them as Haskins does. Whenever Haskins sees one of his players with a woman, he starts ranting about the "nonsense" of romance. When he moves his family into a college dormitory, his wife's confused reaction is barely acknowledged.

For period flavor, Gartner throws Buddy Holly and "The Ballad of the Green Berets" on the soundtrack, but it takes him half the film to discover the subject that is most directly tied to the 1960s: the American apartheid that makes it all but impossible for the team to find lodgings, eat in restaurants and visit a restroom without being beaten.

The chief villain is a racist coach, Adolph Rupp (Jon Voight), whose Kentucky team provides a special challenge to Haskins' boys. Rupp's wife, who carefully announces that she's no bigot, has even less screen time than Haskins' mate.

One of the writers, Gregory Allen Howard, worked on another pair of sports movies, "Ali" and "Remember the Titans," and unfortunately it shows. What the script needs is a writer who can rethink this material, freshen it, refuse to Disneyfy it. But because the producer is Jerry Bruckheimer ("Armageddon," "Bad Boys"), well, that's not going to happen.

"Glory Road" is not without its charms. The locker-room interplay among the teammates has some wit, Derek Luke communicates great charm as the team's star and Lucas fans will be happy to see him taking the leading role for a change.

More movies on MSNBC 

80
Washington Post: Ann Hornaday
From its sepia-toned palette to the Motown hits that drive its terrific soundtrack, Glory Road is utterly authentic. But most astonishing is an unrecognizable Jon Voight as Adolph Rupp.Read Full Review »
75
CHICAGO SUN-TIMES: Roger Ebert
Where it succeeds is as the story of a chapter in history, the story of how one coach at one school arrived at an obvious conclusion and acted on it, and helped open college sports in the South to generations of African Americans.Read Full Review »
75
ReelViews: James Berardinelli
Glory Road's strength is the way in which it blends social awareness into the sports genre.Read Full Review »
70
Salon.com: Stephanie Zacharek
When a movie plays every card, it's bound to win a hand or two. You can't exactly call that approach craftsmanship. But in the case of the Jerry Bruckheimer-produced inspirational sports drama Glory Road, it at least amounts to a kind of blunt effectiveness.Read Full Review »
63
USA Today: Mike Clark
At least a more satisfying basketball saga than last year's "Coach Carter."Read Full Review »
60
The New York Times: Dana Stevens
Glory Road is satisfying less for its virtuosity than for its sincerity, and also because it will acquaint audiences with a remarkable episode that had ramifications far beyond the basketball court.Read Full Review »
60
LOS ANGELES TIMES: Kevin Crust
Ripped directly from Disney's playbook of inspirational sports movies, it's devoid of any original elements that might deter it from that successful formula, hewing closer to the sentimental cliches of "Remember the Titans" than the much better "Miracle" or "The Rookie."Read Full Review »
58
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Lisa Schwarzbaum
Still, it's only just a jump shot or two before Glory Road settles into its rudimentary, music-cued rhythms of classroom civics lessons punctuated by on-court action.Read Full Review »
50
ROLLING STONE: Peter Travers
Josh Lucas plays Haskins with a no-bull vigor that comes in handy when the script saddles him with all-bull platitudes.Read Full Review »
50
Village Voice: Matt Singer
As Coach Haskins would have put it, "It's activity without accomplishment."Read Full Review »
See all Glory Road reviews at metacritic.com »