Employee of the Month

:

Critics' Reviews

advertisement
Metascore
®
36
Generally Unfavorable Reviews
out of 100
'Employee' Belongs in Unemployment Line
By David Germain, Associated Press

Jessica Simpson, Dane Cook, Dax Shepard and colleagues will not be in the running for Hollywood's employee of the month for their new comedy.

In fact, except for standup comic Cook, who manages to come off as likable enough in the dreadful workplace tale "Employee of the Month," everyone else involved belongs in the unemployment line.

In a perfect workaday world, this miserably idiotic movie would put an end to Simpson's alleged acting career (since last year's woeful "The Dukes of Hazzard" had not already done the trick). Simpson's so flat and vacuous, it's an insult to all the equally untalented yet unknown pretty faces looking for a break in Hollywood that she got the role over them.

But she's lovely to just sit and stare at, and she's a pop star whose celebrity makes movie marketers' chores that much easier. So audiences may be stuck with her awhile, until studios and filmmakers decide to stop hiring her because she has no presence on screen.

First-time director Greg Coolidge shares screenwriting credit with Don Calame and Chris Conroy, who wrote the story, and it's a sorry day on the job when it takes the toil of three people to come up with a comedy so lame and gags so pathetic.

The movie is set at a Costco-like SuperClub warehouse bargain store, where bulk shoppers buy condoms by the gross and hair gel by the gallon tub.

Vince (Shepard), an arrogant, malicious little toad, has risen through the ranks to become head cashier and employee of the month 17 straight times. He now aims for a record No. 18, which would win him a "new-ish" Chevy Malibu from the SuperClub corporation.

Slacker Zack (Cook) is Vince's opposite, lazy and easygoing, a guy who's worked at SuperClub for 10 years and never risen above lowly box-boy status. Yet unlike the reviled Vince, Zack is beloved among his co-workers.

When gorgeous cashier Amy (Simpson) transfers in from another store, the rumor goes around that she only dates employees of the month. Vince and Zack both are smitten, the two going head-to-head to win that month's title and, hopefully, Amy's heart.

What follows in this excessively long flick is a succession of empty-headed jokes and pranks, with a lot of repetitive pratfalls where people take nasty bumps to the head.

Cook rises above execrable material to make Zack a somewhat sympathetic guy. Everyone else is a cardboard caricature, including, sadly, Efren Ramirez (Pedro of "Napoleon Dynamite") as Vince's sidekick.

Simpson utters her dialogue with all the personality of a 10-pound can of cling peaches.

"You employees of the month are all the same," Amy grouses at one point, a line that's just deadly dull in Simpson's lifeless delivery.

But it's a potentially sharp and funny line for filmmakers interested in doing something more akin to TV's brilliant "The Office." Something that at least vaguely reflects a real retail world audiences might recognize, rather than just tossing sub-moronic stick figures into cheesy cashier vests and turning them loose on Hollywood movie shoppers. 

Copyright 2006 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Jessica Simpson, Dane Cook, Dax Shepard and colleagues will not be in the running for Hollywood's employee of the month for their new comedy.

In fact, except for standup comic Cook, who manages to come off as likable enough in the dreadful workplace tale "Employee of the Month," everyone else involved belongs in the unemployment line.

In a perfect workaday world, this miserably idiotic movie would put an end to Simpson's alleged acting career (since last year's woeful "The Dukes of Hazzard" had not already done the trick). Simpson's so flat and vacuous, it's an insult to all the equally untalented yet unknown pretty faces looking for a break in Hollywood that she got the role over them.

But she's lovely to just sit and stare at, and she's a pop star whose celebrity makes movie marketers' chores that much easier. So audiences may be stuck with her awhile, until studios and filmmakers decide to stop hiring her because she has no presence on screen.

First-time director Greg Coolidge shares screenwriting credit with Don Calame and Chris Conroy, who wrote the story, and it's a sorry day on the job when it takes the toil of three people to come up with a comedy so lame and gags so pathetic.

The movie is set at a Costco-like SuperClub warehouse bargain store, where bulk shoppers buy condoms by the gross and hair gel by the gallon tub.

Vince (Shepard), an arrogant, malicious little toad, has risen through the ranks to become head cashier and employee of the month 17 straight times. He now aims for a record No. 18, which would win him a "new-ish" Chevy Malibu from the SuperClub corporation.

Slacker Zack (Cook) is Vince's opposite, lazy and easygoing, a guy who's worked at SuperClub for 10 years and never risen above lowly box-boy status. Yet unlike the reviled Vince, Zack is beloved among his co-workers.

When gorgeous cashier Amy (Simpson) transfers in from another store, the rumor goes around that she only dates employees of the month. Vince and Zack both are smitten, the two going head-to-head to win that month's title and, hopefully, Amy's heart.

What follows in this excessively long flick is a succession of empty-headed jokes and pranks, with a lot of repetitive pratfalls where people take nasty bumps to the head.

Cook rises above execrable material to make Zack a somewhat sympathetic guy. Everyone else is a cardboard caricature, including, sadly, Efren Ramirez (Pedro of "Napoleon Dynamite") as Vince's sidekick.

Simpson utters her dialogue with all the personality of a 10-pound can of cling peaches.

"You employees of the month are all the same," Amy grouses at one point, a line that's just deadly dull in Simpson's lifeless delivery.

But it's a potentially sharp and funny line for filmmakers interested in doing something more akin to TV's brilliant "The Office." Something that at least vaguely reflects a real retail world audiences might recognize, rather than just tossing sub-moronic stick figures into cheesy cashier vests and turning them loose on Hollywood movie shoppers. 

Copyright 2006 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

50
LOS ANGELES TIMES: Mark Olsen
This may be a just-for-fun comedy, but that shouldn't mean that it must entirely disconnect from the world.Read Full Review »
40
The New York Times: Jeannette Catsoulis
Employee of the Month is more tired than a Wal-Mart greeter at the end of a Saturday shift. One can only hope its halfhearted suggestion that winning isn't everything is some comfort if the movie's grosses are as disappointing as its jokes.Read Full Review »
38
Boston Globe: Wesley Morris
Perhaps Employee of the Month, which was typed then directed by Greg Coolidge, is unfolding in the key of satire. But you'd have to be a dog to hear it.Read Full Review »
38
Philadelphia Inquirer: David Hiltbrand
So achingly empty, it's nearly existential.Read Full Review »
38
USA Today: Claudia Puig
You're bound to have more fun working overtime than watching Employee of the Month.Read Full Review »
33
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Owen Gleiberman
The results in Employee of the Month are toothless.Read Full Review »
30
Washington Post: Ann Hornaday
Rarely has an actress exuded such blank nothingness as Simpson, a one-woman vapid delivery system who sucks the energy and joy out of every scene she's in, like some freakishly well-endowed black hole.Read Full Review »
25
ROLLING STONE: Peter Travers
I laughed once or twice during this flat and fatuous farce, mainly because director and co-writer Greg Coolidge lifted a lot of it from "Office Space."Read Full Review »
See all Employee of the Month reviews at metacritic.com »