Trailers &
Clips
News
Showtimes &
Tickets
Awards &
Nominations

Eight Below

:

Critics' Reviews

Metascore
®
64
Generally favorable reviews
out of 100
Sled Dogs Steal 'Eight Below'
By John Hartl, film critic, MSNBC

A box-office record-breaker in Japan in the mid-1980s, the Antarctica nature epic "Nankyoku Monogatari (Antarctica)" never caught on in the United States.

But Disney has belatedly come to the rescue with an engaging, thoroughly Americanized remake called "Eight Below." Both films are based on a late-1950s incident involving an expedition that was forced to abandon its sled dogs during a harsh storm.

In the new film, Paul Walker plays the dogs' most devoted pal: an Antarctica guide who can't stop worrying about their fate when he's sent back to the U.S. He and the dogs have saved the life of a geologist (Bruce Greenwood) who's been looking for a meteorite, but winter's coming, escape scenarios are limited, and the dogs are left to fend for themselves.

Greenwood, Walker's best friend (Jason Biggs) and Walker's ex-girlfriend (Moon Bloodgood) all try to help him let go. He persists in moping about in a deep funk in Pasadena, Washington, D.C., and while teaching 9-year-olds to maneuver in kayaks. Meanwhile, the dogs have broken free of their harnesses and learned to survive, mostly by hunting birds and munching on the carcasses of large sea creatures.

Much less maudlin than the 1983 original, "Eight Below" makes use of digital effects, stunt experts, puppeteers and more dog trainers than actors (much of the film was shot in Norway and Canada). The result is a nearly seamless vision of animal/human interaction, with more than a few anthropomorphic touches that recall "The Incredible Journey" and other Disney nature films.

The director, Frank Marshall, knows something about survival dramas, having previously made "Alive," the 1993 drama about an Andes plane crash. He expertly builds suspense from the simplest elements — cracking ice, hidden crevasses, nervous fliers, the arrival of a pair of leopard seals, the threat of frostbite and amputation — and he's not above a horror-movie shocker touch or two.

If you don't jump out of your seat during one episode late in the film, as one of the dogs is looking for food, you're probably asleep. Marshall often seems to revel in emphasizing the less soothing aspects of nature.

He's less secure with the actors, partly because the script presents them with so little to do. The relationships between the characters almost never get in the way, but they're not really worth the screen time they're given either. The Walker/Bloodgood romance is off-again, on-again, and in the end it barely matters.

One scene between Walker and Greenwood promises more. Walker's character has concerns about the safety of the expedition to find the meteorite, but he caves in to please everyone else. Bad decision, as it turns out.

"If you didn't think it was safe," Greenwood points out, "you shouldn't have backed down." Unfortunately, the tension is relieved almost immediately, and the cautionary note is forgotten.

It's too bad the human element is so marginal here. But, like Walker's character, the movie is clearly in love with the dogs. They have distinct personalities and ways of relating, and always manage to hijack their scenes.

More movies on MSNBC 

A box-office record-breaker in Japan in the mid-1980s, the Antarctica nature epic "Nankyoku Monogatari (Antarctica)" never caught on in the United States.

But Disney has belatedly come to the rescue with an engaging, thoroughly Americanized remake called "Eight Below." Both films are based on a late-1950s incident involving an expedition that was forced to abandon its sled dogs during a harsh storm.

In the new film, Paul Walker plays the dogs' most devoted pal: an Antarctica guide who can't stop worrying about their fate when he's sent back to the U.S. He and the dogs have saved the life of a geologist (Bruce Greenwood) who's been looking for a meteorite, but winter's coming, escape scenarios are limited, and the dogs are left to fend for themselves.

Greenwood, Walker's best friend (Jason Biggs) and Walker's ex-girlfriend (Moon Bloodgood) all try to help him let go. He persists in moping about in a deep funk in Pasadena, Washington, D.C., and while teaching 9-year-olds to maneuver in kayaks. Meanwhile, the dogs have broken free of their harnesses and learned to survive, mostly by hunting birds and munching on the carcasses of large sea creatures.

Much less maudlin than the 1983 original, "Eight Below" makes use of digital effects, stunt experts, puppeteers and more dog trainers than actors (much of the film was shot in Norway and Canada). The result is a nearly seamless vision of animal/human interaction, with more than a few anthropomorphic touches that recall "The Incredible Journey" and other Disney nature films.

The director, Frank Marshall, knows something about survival dramas, having previously made "Alive," the 1993 drama about an Andes plane crash. He expertly builds suspense from the simplest elements — cracking ice, hidden crevasses, nervous fliers, the arrival of a pair of leopard seals, the threat of frostbite and amputation — and he's not above a horror-movie shocker touch or two.

If you don't jump out of your seat during one episode late in the film, as one of the dogs is looking for food, you're probably asleep. Marshall often seems to revel in emphasizing the less soothing aspects of nature.

He's less secure with the actors, partly because the script presents them with so little to do. The relationships between the characters almost never get in the way, but they're not really worth the screen time they're given either. The Walker/Bloodgood romance is off-again, on-again, and in the end it barely matters.

One scene between Walker and Greenwood promises more. Walker's character has concerns about the safety of the expedition to find the meteorite, but he caves in to please everyone else. Bad decision, as it turns out.

"If you didn't think it was safe," Greenwood points out, "you shouldn't have backed down." Unfortunately, the tension is relieved almost immediately, and the cautionary note is forgotten.

It's too bad the human element is so marginal here. But, like Walker's character, the movie is clearly in love with the dogs. They have distinct personalities and ways of relating, and always manage to hijack their scenes.

More movies on MSNBC 

83
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Lisa Schwarzbaum
There's something invigorating about this unpretentious dog tale. And if a penguin drops by to promote his own movie product, well, there's room on the frozen continent for all.Read Full Review »
80
Washington Post: Ann Hornaday
Although the dogs have surely been Disney-fied to some extent, the sequences of them trying to survive are magnificent and deeply moving. Bring the Kleenex, and hug your pups when you get home.Read Full Review »
75
CHICAGO SUN-TIMES: Roger Ebert
Remarkable, how in a film where we KNOW with an absolute certainty that all or most of the dogs must survive, Eight Below succeeds as an effective story. It works by focusing on the dogs.Read Full Review »
75
USA Today: Claudia Puig
Walker is adorable, but gives a one-note performance. Greenwood, a charismatic and unsung character actor, has the most noteworthy human performance as a somewhat arrogant academic whose decency keeps him from becoming a stock villain in a formulaic story.Read Full Review »
75
Philadelphia Inquirer: Steven Rea
"March of the Penguins" - phooey! Those smelly little birds are built to survive in the frozen tundra, and nobody's asking them to pull a sled.Read Full Review »
75
Boston Globe: Wesley Morris
It's the most touching love story about tragically separated sexy beasts since "Cold Mountain."Read Full Review »
60
Slate: Emily Yoffe
The dogs learn to fight for themselves and eventually tangle with a (computer-generated) leopard seal in the movie's most thrilling encounter.Read Full Review »
50
LOS ANGELES TIMES: Kevin Crust
This family adventure about a team of sled dogs abandoned in Antarctica naturally invokes the traditional shout of "Mush!" urging the canines to go faster, but it's also an apt descriptor of both its shameless sentimentality and ineptly structured story.Read Full Review »
50
Salon.com: Stephanie Zacharek
This is one of those lazy, lukewarm pictures that's even more disappointing than a purely bad one, and for one glaring reason: How could Marshall, his writers, and even his actors have let these dogs down so badly?Read Full Review »
50
Village Voice: Peter L'Official
A gorgeous art film full of snowy silences and spare, gestural performances threatens to break loose (the most inspired acting comes courtesy of the canines), though the plot's slavish schmaltz proves as oppressive as the harsh winter that descends upon the dogs.Read Full Review »
See all Eight Below reviews at metacritic.com »