Blades of Glory

:

Critics' Reviews

advertisement
Metascore
®
64
Generally favorable reviews
out of 100
'Blades' Is Gloriously Silly
By John Hartl, Film critic, MSNBC

The sheer dreamy silliness of Will Ferrell's new comedy, "Blades of Glory," carries it for a remarkably long time. Even after the movie starts recycling ideas and turns formulaic with an overextended chase sequence, it's impossible to dislike.

The freshness of the storyline, about a pair of ice-skating divas who are forced to work together, must be attributed to a couple of brothers, Jeff Cox and Craig Cox, who had never written a screenplay. They've given Ferrell a chance to stretch as never before, and Jon Heder (from "Napoleon Dynamite") turns out to be an ideal partner.

Heder plays an insufferable child prodigy, Jimmy MacElroy, whose professional skating days are numbered once he indulges in a nasty public confrontation with the macho king of the arena, Chazz Michael Michaels (Ferrell). Their fans are horrified by their juvenile brawl on the ice, Jimmy and Chazz are stripped of their medals and they're forbidden ever to skate again professionally.

Three and a half years later, Jimmy's most rabid fan, an obsessed stalker with a talent for finding legal loopholes, comes up with a plan to get around the ban. Jimmy and Chazz were single skater artists, but there's no rule against them returning as a pair: the first male/male pair in figure-skating history.

The only problem: they hate each other. Indeed, they first attract publicity by beating up on each other in public once more. The rest of the movie deals with their professional and personal progression toward becoming partners, while a couple of mean-spirited rivals (Amy Poehler, Will Arnett) try to destroy their new career.

In addition to the Coxes, three other writers are given script credit, including John Altschuler and Dave Krinsky, who worked on Fox's "King of the Hill" series, and Busy Philipps, a story writer (and actor) on another memorable show, "Freaks and Geeks." But it's clear that the producers, among them Ben Stiller, were first impressed by what the Coxes had created.

"It's just such a funny idea," Stiller claims in the press kit, "so we decided to try to get it made."

It couldn't have been easy. Stunt doubles and special effects certainly helped, but Ferrell and Heder did have to learn to skate reasonably well for several key scenes, and so did Arnett and Poehler. A large part of the fun of the movie is watching such familiar actors daring to take on such daunting physical challenges.

The film's co-directors, Josh Gordon and Will Speck, were nominated for an Oscar for their live-action 1998 short, "Culture," and they've continued as partners with a series of music videos and commercials, including Geico's caveman routine. This is their first feature, and it's a most promising debut.

At its best, "Blades of Glory" recalls Christopher Guest's series of knowing show-biz mockumentaries, especially "Best in Show" and "A Mighty Wind." The filmmakers may lack Guest's interest in supporting actors (William Fichtner is wasted, and Poehler lacks her "Saturday Night Live" verve), but there's no reason to sniff at what they do accomplish.

Also: Who gets to be gay in movies now? 'Blades of Glory' gets the jokes right

More movies on MSNBC 

The sheer dreamy silliness of Will Ferrell's new comedy, "Blades of Glory," carries it for a remarkably long time. Even after the movie starts recycling ideas and turns formulaic with an overextended chase sequence, it's impossible to dislike.

The freshness of the storyline, about a pair of ice-skating divas who are forced to work together, must be attributed to a couple of brothers, Jeff Cox and Craig Cox, who had never written a screenplay. They've given Ferrell a chance to stretch as never before, and Jon Heder (from "Napoleon Dynamite") turns out to be an ideal partner.

Heder plays an insufferable child prodigy, Jimmy MacElroy, whose professional skating days are numbered once he indulges in a nasty public confrontation with the macho king of the arena, Chazz Michael Michaels (Ferrell). Their fans are horrified by their juvenile brawl on the ice, Jimmy and Chazz are stripped of their medals and they're forbidden ever to skate again professionally.

Three and a half years later, Jimmy's most rabid fan, an obsessed stalker with a talent for finding legal loopholes, comes up with a plan to get around the ban. Jimmy and Chazz were single skater artists, but there's no rule against them returning as a pair: the first male/male pair in figure-skating history.

The only problem: they hate each other. Indeed, they first attract publicity by beating up on each other in public once more. The rest of the movie deals with their professional and personal progression toward becoming partners, while a couple of mean-spirited rivals (Amy Poehler, Will Arnett) try to destroy their new career.

In addition to the Coxes, three other writers are given script credit, including John Altschuler and Dave Krinsky, who worked on Fox's "King of the Hill" series, and Busy Philipps, a story writer (and actor) on another memorable show, "Freaks and Geeks." But it's clear that the producers, among them Ben Stiller, were first impressed by what the Coxes had created.

"It's just such a funny idea," Stiller claims in the press kit, "so we decided to try to get it made."

It couldn't have been easy. Stunt doubles and special effects certainly helped, but Ferrell and Heder did have to learn to skate reasonably well for several key scenes, and so did Arnett and Poehler. A large part of the fun of the movie is watching such familiar actors daring to take on such daunting physical challenges.

The film's co-directors, Josh Gordon and Will Speck, were nominated for an Oscar for their live-action 1998 short, "Culture," and they've continued as partners with a series of music videos and commercials, including Geico's caveman routine. This is their first feature, and it's a most promising debut.

At its best, "Blades of Glory" recalls Christopher Guest's series of knowing show-biz mockumentaries, especially "Best in Show" and "A Mighty Wind." The filmmakers may lack Guest's interest in supporting actors (William Fichtner is wasted, and Poehler lacks her "Saturday Night Live" verve), but there's no reason to sniff at what they do accomplish.

Also: Who gets to be gay in movies now? 'Blades of Glory' gets the jokes right

More movies on MSNBC 

90
Washington Post: Stephen Hunter
To see seemingly reg'lar guys utterly stripped of dignity and defense is cruel enough, but crueler still is the laughter that you cannot seem to stop from rupturing your lungs and aorta.Read Full Review »
75
Boston Globe: Wesley Morris
The film is quick, painless, and more than a little brave: not since John Travolta, Jamie Lee Curtis, and the aerobicizers in "Perfect" has so much Lycra been so abused for our pleasure.Read Full Review »
70
Time: Richard Corliss
It has the slapdash air of a movie that was a little more fun to shoot than to watch. To say that Blades is a little sharper than "Kicking and Screaming," but not nearly so smart as the best parts of "Talladega," is like taste-testing a Big Mac against a Whopper and a Wendy's Classic Double.Read Full Review »
70
The New York Times: Stephen Holden
Fast, light, frequently funny comedy.Read Full Review »
70
LOS ANGELES TIMES: Kevin Crust
The movie is at its funniest and most original when zinging the sometimes pretentious milieu of competitive figure skating. Whatever combination of choreography, camera trickery and special effects were required to render the over-the-top, hyper-real skate numbers, they're executed with wit and ingenuity.Read Full Review »
67
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Owen Gleiberman
Blades of Glory has funny moves even when its characters can barely move, but the film seldom gets past its one basic laugh: that a real man figure-skating is a contradiction in terms.Read Full Review »
63
Philadelphia Inquirer: Steven Rea
Dumb with a capital D, Blades of Glory takes its (almost) fleshed-out sketch-comedy idea as far as an ice-skating buddy movie with we're-not-gay jokes and a psycho stalker can go.Read Full Review »
63
USA Today: Claudia Puig
Part of the problem lies in the casting imbalance: Ferrell is so much more adept at this comedy style than Heder.Read Full Review »
60
Slate: Dana Stevens
No project involving Ferrell is going to be entirely unfunny, and Blades of Glory does have its moments of loopy ingenuity, even if none of them goes quite far enough.Read Full Review »
50
ROLLING STONE: Peter Travers
The villains, an incestuous brother and sister played by real-life marrieds Amy Poehler and Will Arnett are a hoot. And "Office" honey Jenna Fischer is welcome as Jimmy’s love.Read Full Review »
See all Blades of Glory reviews at metacritic.com »