Bee Movie

:

Critics' Reviews

Metascore
®
54
Mixed or Average Reviews
out of 100
Seinfeld's 'Bee' Short on Originality
By Todd McCarthy, Variety.com

Amiable but no more, "Bee Movie" puts a hiveful of potent talent at the service of a zig-zigging, back-of-an-envelope story that's short on surprise and originality. Long sought for animation work, producer-writer-star Jerry Seinfeld contents himself with whimsical notions and mild jokes in creating an independent-minded bee who breaks with protocol to forge a relationship with a human, to less than inspired results. Seinfeld's name, a huge push by Paramount/DreamWorks Animation and the venture's mainstream innocuousness should combine for a sweet if not blockbuster box office.

Jerry Seinfeld
Video: MSN talks to Seinfeld and Warburton

Seinfeld's patented quirky humor does lend this cross-pollinating tale a distinctive personality, one notably less crass and pandering than that found in such other DreamWorks toons as "Shark Tale" and the "Shrek" sequels. The effort's gentleness and modesty are not unappealing, but these qualities simultaneously provide the picture with an underwhelming impact, and, given the déjà vu aspect of certain key elements, contribute to its overall ho-hum-ness.

The opening stretch recalls DreamWorks' first animated venture, "Antz," with its portrait of a highly regimented community and focus on one youngster who'd prefer to go his own way. "We're the most perfectly functioning society on Earth," insists Adam (voiced by Matthew Broderick), best pal of Barry (Seinfeld), as the two graduate from school and are obliged to commit themselves to lifelong jobs with honey conglomerate Honex. Despite the pic's beguiling view of the bee community as one big playground, Barry slips off to join the "pollen jocks," macho aviators who are the only bees allowed to leave the hive.

See Also: MSN's Cinemama reviews 'Bee Movie'

His squadron's flight into Central Park and Manhattan constitutes the film's most exuberant, visually adventurous passage. Initially exhilarated by all he sees as the heavy-bellied, yellow-and-black pilots bomb around town, Barry becomes imperiled by a tennis ball and racquet before landing inside an apartment. There, a kind florist, Vanessa (Renée Zellweger), prevents Barry from being swatted by putting a glass over him so she can put him outside.

Despite the strict bee-world commandment against speaking with humans, Barry feels so grateful to Vanessa that he initiates communication with her. Unfortunately, in this crucial scene, Vanessa is animated to gesticulate and make faces in such an exaggerated and off-puttingly mechanical way that it takes a good while to embrace the character, whose empathetic instincts warm Barry's cockles, if a bee's heart has such.

Revealing to his busy-bee parents (Kathy Bates, Barry Levinson) that he's "met someone," Barry is asked by his mom, "Was she beeish?" To which he replies that she's "not a wasp." Such jokes continue as the script (penned by Seinfeld, former "Seinfeld" writers Spike Feresten and Andy Robin, and Barry Marder, author of the "Letters From a Nut" tomes) pursues a parallel with "The Graduate" that becomes explicit with a homage to the latter's famous swimming pool scene. Barry simply can't decide what he wants to do with his life, so he follows a line of perfectly modern logic: When in doubt, sue.

So whom does Barry sue? Why, the entire human race, for "stealing" the honey Barry's fellow bees so industriously produce for what they thought was their own benefit. A much-publicized trial ensues, with a verdict that yields unanticipated consequences for man and bug, but which ultimately clears the way for greater mutual understanding between the species.

It's a goofy but wispy concept, one hardly developed in ways that charge the emotions or one's sense of justice. Nor does the critter/human dynamic here possess the crucial interdependence that it did, for example, in this summer's "Ratatouille." Directors Simon J. Smith ("Shrek 4-D") and Steve Hickner ("The Prince of Egypt") move things along agreeably, and while the visuals are awash with vibrant colors, they lack the intricacy, detail and facial nuance of the best computer animation; both "Antz" and "Monsters, Inc.," for example, provide infinitely more worked-out hidden worlds for their characters to inhabit.

The voicings by an array of top talent are fun, and the musical backing provides some bounce.

Also: Get the 'Bee Movie' Vista gadget

More on Variety.com

Copyright 2007 Variety, Inc. All rights reserved.

Amiable but no more, "Bee Movie" puts a hiveful of potent talent at the service of a zig-zigging, back-of-an-envelope story that's short on surprise and originality. Long sought for animation work, producer-writer-star Jerry Seinfeld contents himself with whimsical notions and mild jokes in creating an independent-minded bee who breaks with protocol to forge a relationship with a human, to less than inspired results. Seinfeld's name, a huge push by Paramount/DreamWorks Animation and the venture's mainstream innocuousness should combine for a sweet if not blockbuster box office.

Jerry Seinfeld
Video: MSN talks to Seinfeld and Warburton

Seinfeld's patented quirky humor does lend this cross-pollinating tale a distinctive personality, one notably less crass and pandering than that found in such other DreamWorks toons as "Shark Tale" and the "Shrek" sequels. The effort's gentleness and modesty are not unappealing, but these qualities simultaneously provide the picture with an underwhelming impact, and, given the déjà vu aspect of certain key elements, contribute to its overall ho-hum-ness.

The opening stretch recalls DreamWorks' first animated venture, "Antz," with its portrait of a highly regimented community and focus on one youngster who'd prefer to go his own way. "We're the most perfectly functioning society on Earth," insists Adam (voiced by Matthew Broderick), best pal of Barry (Seinfeld), as the two graduate from school and are obliged to commit themselves to lifelong jobs with honey conglomerate Honex. Despite the pic's beguiling view of the bee community as one big playground, Barry slips off to join the "pollen jocks," macho aviators who are the only bees allowed to leave the hive.

See Also: MSN's Cinemama reviews 'Bee Movie'

His squadron's flight into Central Park and Manhattan constitutes the film's most exuberant, visually adventurous passage. Initially exhilarated by all he sees as the heavy-bellied, yellow-and-black pilots bomb around town, Barry becomes imperiled by a tennis ball and racquet before landing inside an apartment. There, a kind florist, Vanessa (Renée Zellweger), prevents Barry from being swatted by putting a glass over him so she can put him outside.

Despite the strict bee-world commandment against speaking with humans, Barry feels so grateful to Vanessa that he initiates communication with her. Unfortunately, in this crucial scene, Vanessa is animated to gesticulate and make faces in such an exaggerated and off-puttingly mechanical way that it takes a good while to embrace the character, whose empathetic instincts warm Barry's cockles, if a bee's heart has such.

Revealing to his busy-bee parents (Kathy Bates, Barry Levinson) that he's "met someone," Barry is asked by his mom, "Was she beeish?" To which he replies that she's "not a wasp." Such jokes continue as the script (penned by Seinfeld, former "Seinfeld" writers Spike Feresten and Andy Robin, and Barry Marder, author of the "Letters From a Nut" tomes) pursues a parallel with "The Graduate" that becomes explicit with a homage to the latter's famous swimming pool scene. Barry simply can't decide what he wants to do with his life, so he follows a line of perfectly modern logic: When in doubt, sue.

So whom does Barry sue? Why, the entire human race, for "stealing" the honey Barry's fellow bees so industriously produce for what they thought was their own benefit. A much-publicized trial ensues, with a verdict that yields unanticipated consequences for man and bug, but which ultimately clears the way for greater mutual understanding between the species.

It's a goofy but wispy concept, one hardly developed in ways that charge the emotions or one's sense of justice. Nor does the critter/human dynamic here possess the crucial interdependence that it did, for example, in this summer's "Ratatouille." Directors Simon J. Smith ("Shrek 4-D") and Steve Hickner ("The Prince of Egypt") move things along agreeably, and while the visuals are awash with vibrant colors, they lack the intricacy, detail and facial nuance of the best computer animation; both "Antz" and "Monsters, Inc.," for example, provide infinitely more worked-out hidden worlds for their characters to inhabit.

The voicings by an array of top talent are fun, and the musical backing provides some bounce.

Also: Get the 'Bee Movie' Vista gadget

More on Variety.com

Copyright 2007 Variety, Inc. All rights reserved.

91
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Owen Gleiberman
Agreeably skewed fun.Read Full Review »
75
Boston Globe: Ty Burr
The movie's not even close to Pixar standards - the animation is slapdash and the story construction's a mess - but the vibe is loose-limbed and fluky, and the gags have an extra snap that's recognizably Seinfeldian.Read Full Review »
75
ROLLING STONE: Peter Travers
At its relaxed best, when it's about, well, nothing, the slyly comic Bee Movie is truly beguiling.Read Full Review »
75
Philadelphia Inquirer: Steven Rea
It has enough buzzing wit and eye-popping animation to win over the kids - and probably more than a few parents, too.Read Full Review »
70
The New York Times: A.O. Scott
The real fun is the insect shtick.Read Full Review »
70
NewsWeek: David Ansen
I'm not sure what kids are going to make of Bee Movie. The shiny, vivid computer-animated images pop off the screen with the vibrancy of the Pixar movies, but the understated, throwaway humor is pure Seinfeld: adult, observational, feasting on the small ironies of human (make that "beeish") behavior.Read Full Review »
63
ReelViews: James Berardinelli
On the whole, this is another disappointing animated effort and it resides considerably lower on the totem pole than this year's current non-live action champion, "Ratatouille."Read Full Review »
60
Slate: Dana Stevens
The movie's more than cute, funny, and (at 81 minutes) brisk enough to move families in and out of the multiplex in mass quantities, like the social insects we are.Read Full Review »
50
Salon.com: Stephanie Zacharek
Just another ambitious, lavish animated adventure, pretty enough to look at, but ultimately foundering on the weakness of its script.Read Full Review »
50
LOS ANGELES TIMES: Carina Chocano
There's no real jeopardy. The stakes are low. It's a bee movie about nothing.Read Full Review »
See all Bee Movie reviews at metacritic.com »