Babel

:

Critics' Reviews

Metascore
®
69
Generally favorable reviews
out of 100
'Babel' an Intricate Puzzle
By John Hartl, Film critic, MSNBC

Never one to tell a straightforward story straightforwardly, the Mexican director Alejandro González Iñárritu ("21 Grams," "Amores Perros") thrives on complications and fractured narratives. His third feature, "Babel," offers plenty more of the same.

Working once again with screenwriter Guillermo Arriaga (who also wrote "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada"), Inarritu has constructed an intricate puzzle movie that takes some wild leaps off the diving board and mostly justifies the gamble. If the experiment goes on too long (143 minutes), and if one of the stories is less than compelling, "Babel" still has many glorious touches.

Chief among them is the way two stories intersect in Morocco. A pair of American tourists (Brad Pitt, Cate Blanchett) are quarreling about why they've chosen to visit the country and leave their children with their housekeeper. Unknown to them, she's taken the kids from San Diego to Mexico to celebrate her son's wedding.

Meanwhile, two young Moroccan goatherds are trying out their new gun in a sparsely populated desert area. One takes aim at the Americans' tourist bus, not meaning to do much more than establish the gun's range, but the bullet shatters a window and hits Blanchett, and in no time the incident has set off a terrorist alert.

Meanwhile, back in Tokyo (yes, that's quite a leap, and it's not one of the more welcome ones), a deaf-mute teenager (Rinko Kikuchi) is dealing with her mother's suicide and her father's apparent estrangement from her. She acts out her trauma by stripping for strangers and teasing a boy who seems to reject her.

As it turns out, there is a direct connection between the folks in Japan and the ones in Morocco, but too many coincidences create a strain on the storyline. Also too much is the housekeeper's desperate border crossing. How much trouble can one family attract in one weekend? This one seems downright disaster-prone.

Nevertheless, Iñárritu does succeed in creating a compelling and unnerving sense of dislocation by presenting several points of view, and several perceptions of the consequences, almost simultaneously. Essential to this effect are the contributions of composer Gustavo Santaolalla and cinematographer Rodrigo Prieto (reunited after their work on "Brokeback Mountain").

The privileged tourists see one kind of crisis; the Moroccans see quite another. The tourist may lose his wife and children; the goatherd family and the housekeeper may lose everything. Class, race, religion and income make all the difference in how their worlds, separate yet the same, are perceived. Acting on their own interpretation of the situation, officials immediately interpret the accident as part of a conspiracy.

"When Worlds Collide" might have been a more appropriate title for "Babel," which is especially effective in blending well-known actors with unknowns. Pitt and Blanchette, both deglamourized, are never really the stars.

Neither is Gael García Bernal, who has a key role as the housekeeper's impatient nephew in the Mexican sequence, or Kikuchi, a 24-year-old actress who successfully impersonates a character who's nearly a decade younger. They're all supporting players in a story that's much bigger and more complicated than any of them.

More movies on MSNBC 

Never one to tell a straightforward story straightforwardly, the Mexican director Alejandro González Iñárritu ("21 Grams," "Amores Perros") thrives on complications and fractured narratives. His third feature, "Babel," offers plenty more of the same.

Working once again with screenwriter Guillermo Arriaga (who also wrote "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada"), Inarritu has constructed an intricate puzzle movie that takes some wild leaps off the diving board and mostly justifies the gamble. If the experiment goes on too long (143 minutes), and if one of the stories is less than compelling, "Babel" still has many glorious touches.

Chief among them is the way two stories intersect in Morocco. A pair of American tourists (Brad Pitt, Cate Blanchett) are quarreling about why they've chosen to visit the country and leave their children with their housekeeper. Unknown to them, she's taken the kids from San Diego to Mexico to celebrate her son's wedding.

Meanwhile, two young Moroccan goatherds are trying out their new gun in a sparsely populated desert area. One takes aim at the Americans' tourist bus, not meaning to do much more than establish the gun's range, but the bullet shatters a window and hits Blanchett, and in no time the incident has set off a terrorist alert.

Meanwhile, back in Tokyo (yes, that's quite a leap, and it's not one of the more welcome ones), a deaf-mute teenager (Rinko Kikuchi) is dealing with her mother's suicide and her father's apparent estrangement from her. She acts out her trauma by stripping for strangers and teasing a boy who seems to reject her.

As it turns out, there is a direct connection between the folks in Japan and the ones in Morocco, but too many coincidences create a strain on the storyline. Also too much is the housekeeper's desperate border crossing. How much trouble can one family attract in one weekend? This one seems downright disaster-prone.

Nevertheless, Iñárritu does succeed in creating a compelling and unnerving sense of dislocation by presenting several points of view, and several perceptions of the consequences, almost simultaneously. Essential to this effect are the contributions of composer Gustavo Santaolalla and cinematographer Rodrigo Prieto (reunited after their work on "Brokeback Mountain").

The privileged tourists see one kind of crisis; the Moroccans see quite another. The tourist may lose his wife and children; the goatherd family and the housekeeper may lose everything. Class, race, religion and income make all the difference in how their worlds, separate yet the same, are perceived. Acting on their own interpretation of the situation, officials immediately interpret the accident as part of a conspiracy.

"When Worlds Collide" might have been a more appropriate title for "Babel," which is especially effective in blending well-known actors with unknowns. Pitt and Blanchette, both deglamourized, are never really the stars.

Neither is Gael García Bernal, who has a key role as the housekeeper's impatient nephew in the Mexican sequence, or Kikuchi, a 24-year-old actress who successfully impersonates a character who's nearly a decade younger. They're all supporting players in a story that's much bigger and more complicated than any of them.

More movies on MSNBC 

100
ROLLING STONE: Peter Travers
In the year's richest, most complex and ultimately most heartbreaking film, Inarritu invites us to get past the babble of modern civilization and start listening to each other.Read Full Review »
88
ReelViews: James Berardinelli
Its complex (yet not mystifying) storytelling, forceful character development, and superb cinematography make this a candidate for one of 2006's best offerings.Read Full Review »
88
USA Today: Claudia Puig
Babel may be the most ambitious movie of the year, tackling towering communication barriers, global politics and cultural divides in a structurally complex and fascinating narrative.Read Full Review »
80
Slate: Dana Stevens
Babel has great expectations for itself: It wants to be a movie about big ideas and big emotions at the same time. Aided by gorgeous locations and classy trappings (cinematography by Rodrigo Prieto, theme music by Gustavo Santaolalla), it succeeds for the most part.Read Full Review »
80
The New York Times: A.O. Scott
In the end Babel, like that tower in the book of Genesis, is a grand wreck, an incomplete monument to its own limitless ambition. But it is there, on the landscape, a startling and imposing reality. It's a folly, and also, perversely, a wonder.Read Full Review »
80
Time: Richard Schickel
Babel is a movie that leaves you feeling limp and wrung out, but mysteriously moved by its vivid human encounters with the hot, tightly wired, chancy and coincidental world, ever capable of terrorizing us when we least expect it.Read Full Review »
80
LOS ANGELES TIMES: Carina Chocano
The beauty of this film is in its lapidary details, which sparkle with feeling and surprise.Read Full Review »
70
Salon.com: Andrew O'Hehir
I hate to criticize anybody for artistic ambition, but the problem with Babel isn't that it's a bad movie. It's a good movie, or, more accurately, it's several pieces of good movie, chopped up in service of a pretentious, portentous and slightly silly artistic vision.Read Full Review »
67
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Lisa Schwarzbaum
Measured in anything other than biblical cubits, the sum of Babel's many parts turns out to be a picture that suggests Americans ought to stay home and treat their nannies better.Read Full Review »
63
Boston Globe: Ty Burr
Babel is a ziggurat of brilliant pieces built on sand. It's also this season's "Crash," a movie you know is Important because it never stops telling you so.Read Full Review »
See all Babel reviews at metacritic.com »