This thorough original is a wall-to-wall exercise in gallows humor, a movie whose full funny/sad effect doesn't hit until you reflect upon the subject and the cast of characters.Read Full Review »
80
Slate: David Edelstein
As I watched American Movie, a lot of it struck me as untranscendent misery. But in hindsight it seems less hopeless.Read Full Review »
80
NewsWeek: Andrea C. Basora
Like its subject, American Movie works entirely on its own quirky terms.Read Full Review »
75
ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY: Lisa Schwarzbaum
A tacit auteur-to-auteur endorsement of the inalienable right to make movies--regardless of talent or sobriety or adult responsibilities--is what gives American Movie its uneasy kick.Read Full Review »
70
Village Voice: Amy Taubin
Although I don't begrudge Borchardt his year of fame, what he doesn't seem to understand about his exploitation creeps me out.Read Full Review »
70
LOS ANGELES TIMES: Kevin Thomas
Although overly long at 107 minutes, American Movie is an incisive, largely absorbing work and a far more mature effort than Smith's "American Job."Read Full Review »